Leafs are far better on the back end and they have a goalie who was second in the league in Save % if I remember correctly.
I know this, Florida will be the favourite but each pick up the Leafs made was designed to address this matchup.
Here are the scores for each game two years ago:
4 Of the 5 games were decided by one goal. Two OT wins for Florida. The Leafs played more of a rushing game, whereas this season they played a more defensive, button down game with far better personnel on the backend to play this style. They sacrificed the body more to play low event hockey for many stretches.
For the record, the Senators are probably the fastest team in the conference. Young and fast with no concern in the world. Reminded me of the Leafs putting a scare into the Capitals in the First Round a couple of years before they won the Cup.
I my opinion the greatest asset in hockey is speed, especially if the league decides to call penalties as they have moreso this playoff season than in the past.
Here is the Leafs D in that 2023 series (and their age):
I noticed they focused plenty on Lilly, a young, soft D Man. TJ Brodie is also a skating D Man, not very hard on the body. Schenn is a monster, which is why he was picked up and he was a wall for the team. He and McCabe were the only really "strong" D Men tasked with dealing with a forechecking Florida team.
This is the Leafs D this year that will start Game One against Florida:
Big, reliable Carlo, shot blocking ShutDown pairing of Tanev and McCabe. Simon "Bonecrusher" Benoit who loves to hit. OEL who is far meaner than people give him credit for (and has some offensive bursts), and, Reilly who was the leading scorer for ALL Leafs in that series and generally had a strong series.
The Leafs were having some difficulty with Senators speed, it made it difficult for the Leafs forwards to press forward AND play their system of helping on D. They system is better built to withstand Panthers style hockey in a series. That extra step in a foot race is exceedingly important.
This battle will come down to what I anticipated mid way through this season if the Leafs were to be successful (they did win the division, lost only 3 games all year when leading after the First Period, and Stolarz did have an 11 game win streak to finish the season if I remember correctly):
the Leafs defense should be better able to prevent the driving Florida forwards from playing their game.
Low scoring with a more unruly Panthers team that may take a few too many penalties and risk losing the special teams battle. Leafs could win this in seven and I guarantee that they are quietly more confident than anyone gives them credit for.
This team is far better suited for the Panthers at this time of the year than 2023. Whether this results in a different outcome is to be decided. The puck can go either way in OT and there will be some OT games.