When Chia traded #19 he put all his chips on the table. He got 2 NHL players and 2 prospects who were knocking at the door, plus opened up the cap space for 1 year of Iginla, knowing that deal was going to hurt them the following year. He went all in for one year and had arguably the best team in the NHL in 13-14. They were deep at F, if someone went down they had guys who could step in. They could have used some more depth at D when Seidenberg went down, but they were still more than capable. They had no competition in the east, and the only other competition they had in the NHL were Chicago and LA. They absolutely should have gone to the finals that year, and choked like crazy against Montreal in round two. While I appreciate how bold it was to make that move, Chia had an opportunity and he made the most of it for his open cup window, it was still a failure.
That failure put them in cap hell, caused them to make bad trades to get out of it, and the lack of good drafting under the pre-Gretzky regime had no talent ready to replace the vets who were going out. Add in ownerships unwillingness to rebuild properly and we end up with 2 DNQ and possibly a 3rd right now. At this point, even if we get in, are we looking at Washington in round one? A quick 4 games that'll be, don't quite see the point there other than to placate the boss in Buffalo. I think we've drafted well the last couple years, and we're going to see the fruits of that soon (already started with Carlo), but we would be in a much better position had we moved Eriksson last year and Soderberg the year before that.
Will the incoming talent of D be blossoming while we still have a very good Bergeron and Marchand? That's my biggest fear right now, the F and D are not synched up, our F core is fine but our D is either too old or too young. When the D is fine, what about the F core? We have a championship F core led by those two (and are wasting what might be the peak of Marchand's career) that might be passed it's use by date by the time the D is ready. It all goes back to the drafting under Chiarelli.