Full spoilers:
- Ambrose Asylum to open the show with Shane McMahon. Owens, Zayn and Jericho all interrupted. Shane McMahon sets up Jericho vs. Ambrose and Owens vs. Zayn for Payback. Sets up Jericho vs. Zayn and Owens vs. Ambrose for the show.
- Chris Jericho defeats Sami Zayn with a codebreaker in a good back-and-forth match.
- AJ Styles interview interrupted by Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson, who tell AJ that they have his back at Payback.
- Enzo & Cass defeat The Dudley Boyz to advance to the finals of the tag-team tournament.
- Reigns and AJ Styles have an in-ring segment. Karl Anderson and Luke Gallows attack Roman Reigns and lay him out with the Magic Killer as AJ Styles watches from the bottom of the ramp.
- AJ Styles tells Roman Reigns he had nothing to do with the attack.
- Baron Corbin defeat Fandango with Dolph Ziggler on commentary. Ziggler attacked Corbin post-match, but Corbin laid him out.
- MizTV with Cesaro as the guest. The League of Nations comes out and then The New Day come out.
- Cesaro & The New Day defeat The League of Nations and The Miz when Cesaro pins Sheamus with the Neutralizer.
- Backstage interview where Natalya informs Charlotte she has a Women's Title match at Payback and that Bret Hart will be in her corner.
- Natalya, Sasha Banks, Becky Lynch & Paige defeat Tamina, Naomi, Charlotte & Summer Rae in an 8-women tag team match when Natalya submits Charlotte.
- The Vaudevillains defeat The Usos to advance to the finals of the tag-team tournament and face Enzo & Cass.
- Apollo Crews defeat Heath Slater.
- Dean Ambrose defeat Kevin Owens in the main event with Dirty Deeds. Chris Jericho hits Ambrose with the codebreaker and leaves him lying to close the show.