I think you nailed it, including the root cause.Me too, but I also feel like good teams stay away from guys like him. He can eat minutes, he can do things on offense, but he’s not great at just limiting mistakes in a 2nd or 3rd pairing role.
I was a Risto truther, but at this point I don’t think he’ll change. You know the “can’t walk and chew gum at the same time” shtick? That’s Risto with outlet passes, he can’t skate and make a pass to save his life. I feel like the habits came from being thrown to the wolves on awful Sabres squads and just having to chip it off the boards all the time, and he’s just never grown from that. You can see him thinking out there, it never comes naturally.
Anyways, will be curious to see if he moves. Maybe Edmonton or someone seriously in need of help.
I asked Sabres fans about him halfway through his rookie year and they seemed genuinely happy to have finally got the legit 1D they needed. (This was before Dahlin's drafting, obviously.) Clearly he didn't appear to be so braindead then. 20-20 hindsight and all that, but he would have needed a solid good vet to mentor and shelter him from the get go.
By season three most everyone was getting sick and tired of his defensive brainfarts despite the offensive tools. And the physicality perpetually had the flip side of truly dumb penalties. [My really scorchio takes are only getting hotter...]
Some come carrying the toolbox, some don't and need it developed for them. He didn't.
His value now? Beats me. Chances of evolving? Slim but still there.