They DID go all in on Eichel but the Pegulas, out of spite, absolutely f***ED the NYR because of a petty media feud strung up by fans. It was ridiculous. Then BUF trades Jack for literal peanuts (minus Tuch) out to Vegas. Rangers get shafted even when they're actively trying to do some real business. That's how it's been since forever. Certain GMs don't want to do business with a market like NY because it's too many eyes.
Had the Sabres agreed to the Rangers offer they'd be sitting pretty here with guys like Buchnevich and possibly Laf and the Rangers most likely would've had a cup in 22' or this year, it would've been a win-win.
Same type of thing will happen with Brady Tkachuk, he will finally ask out, Rangers will press hard with a huge overpay offer but of course Ottawa out of spite will turn their heads and walk away and probably gift him to the Devils or Flyers. Heaven forbid an asset you like goes to the Rangers. That just can't happen.