Prospect Rankings - Submit Your Complete List

[Fil Larkmanthanasiou]

1 ASP
2 Buchelnikov
3 Cossa
4 Danielson
5 Kasper
6 MBN
7 Ammo
8 Augustine
9 Finnie
10 Mazur
10 Wallinder

 

[Voodoo Glow Skulls]

1 ASP
2 Buchelnikov
3 Cossa
4 Danielson
5 Kasper
6 MBN
7 Ammo
8 Augustine
9 Finnie
10 Wallinder

Good ranking.

 

[Fil Larkmanthanasiou]

Good ranking.

Thanks. I just edited it to add Mazur

 

[lilidk]

1. Cossa , starter#1 goaltender
2. ASP , second line rd PP specialist
3. Danielson , potential second line center
4. MBN , not a line driver , but could become first line wing
5. Mazur, the most NHL ready prospect, could play anywhere
6. Lombardi, mid six forward
7. Soderblom, mid six forward
8. Buchelnikov, mid six forward
9. Augustine, #2 goaltender
10. Buium , third pair defansman

 

[Frk It]

Did we ever tally these? Should we do an new thread with updated rankings and actually tally them this time?

 

[Winger98]

I've been trying really hard to not encourage another prospect ranking yet

 

[Frk It]

I've been trying really hard to not encourage another prospect ranking yet

To be clear I do not want 10 + new poll threads here… just a submit your list kind of deal which we tally at some point.

 

[Winger98]

To be clear I do not want 10 + new poll threads here… just a submit your list kind of deal which we tally at some point.

maybe during the four nations tournament would be a good time. Wings will be off and it'll give us something to do. One week of voting, then I can post the results?

 

[OgeeOgelthorpe]

1. Cleveland (He is the savior and will lead us to many cups.)
2. Cossa
3. ASP
4. Augustine
5. Danielson
6. MBN
7. Buchelnikov
8. Mazur
9. Soderblom
10. Buium
11. Lombardi
12. Kiiskanen
13. Finnie
14. Plante (I could see him jumping up to the top 10 pretty easily, and top 5 in 2 years.)
15. Wallinder (I was super bullish on him after his D+2 and D+3 but I think he's trade bait at this point.)
16. Tuomisto
17. Anton Johansson
18. NDN
19. LDN
20. Becher (Could jump. We'll see)

 

[Winged Wheel Willy]

1. Cleveland (He is the savior and will lead us to many cups.)
2. Cossa
3. ASP
4. Augustine
5. Danielson
6. MBN
7. Buchelnikov
8. Mazur
9. Soderblom
10. Buium
11. Lombardi
12. Kiiskanen
13. Finnie
14. Plante (I could see him jumping up to the top 10 pretty easily, and top 5 in 2 years.)
15. Wallinder (I was super bullish on him after his D+2 and D+3 but I think he's trade bait at this point.)
16. Tuomisto
17. Anton Johansson
18. NDN
19. LDN
20. Becher (Could jump. We'll see)

At what point in time do we have the discussion, if it is ever gonna happen for Söderblom? Not trying to be cute, serious question.

Mostly agree with the list BTW. Especially Augustine, who I'am also very high on.

 

[19 for president]

Assume Kasper, Aljo, and Ed are fully graduated.

1. ASP
2. Cossa
3. Buchelnikov
4. Danielson
5. Augustine
6. MBN
7. Lombardi
8. Plante
9. Finnie
10. Mazur (his injury luck is really starting to be concerning)
11. Kiiskanen
12. Wallinder
13. Buium
14. Anton Johanssen
15. Soderblom

 

[OgeeOgelthorpe]

At what point in time do we have the discussion, if it is ever gonna happen for Söderblom? Not trying to be cute, serious question.

Mostly agree with the list BTW. Especially Augustine, who I'am also very high on.

You don't need to be a top 3 prospect in the org to become a graduated prospect.

I think Soderblom could make it as a 3rd or 4th line LW. And at this stage I don't see him as any worse an option than Rasmussen who has been ice cold for the past what, 6 weeks? What Soderblom lacks in defensive acumen (in comparison to Rasmussen) he more than makes up for in physicality and hands. He's been a physical monster in Grand Rapids this year. And I think if he plays with a center that has some skill and playmaking he'd be able to unlock some scoring at the NHL level. Maybe he's a 15-20 goal, 30 point guy 3rd liner that gets PP2 time and can play spot duty on the 2nd line during injuries?

 

[Our Lady Peace]

I recently added my list I think pre-WJC in another thread, but I'm revising it semi-regularly

1) Nate Danielson
2) Sebastian Cossa
3) Axel Sandin-Pellikka
4) Trey Augustine
5) Michael Brandsegg-Nygard
6) Dmitri Buchelnikov
7) Amadeus Lombardi
8) Carter Mazur
9) Max Plante
10) Shai Buium
11) Elmer Soderblom
12) Emmitt Finnie
13) Jesse Kiiskinen
14) Dylan James
15) William Wallinder
16) Brady Cleveland
17) Anton Johansson
18) Ondrej Becher
19) Red Savage
20) Antti Tuomisto

 

[Realgud]

@jaster hasnt been active since early november... I hope youre ok!

 

[heyfolks]

At what point in time do we have the discussion, if it is ever gonna happen for Söderblom? Not trying to be cute, serious question.

Mostly agree with the list BTW. Especially Augustine, who I'am also very high on.

ANSWER: October 7 or so 2025

He is out of waiver exemptions. Motte and Fischer are UFAs after the season. He will likely get the opportunity to replace one of them. (The Wings may also move or, buy out Tarasenko.)

Red Wings' Elmer Söderblom Entering Critical Season - The Hockey Writers Red Wings Prospects Latest News, Analysis & More

Winger Elmer Söderblom's 2024-25 campaign is critical to his future as a member of the Detroit Red Wings organization.

thehockeywriters.com

 

[Barry Amsterdam]

1-ASP (+1)
2-Buchelnikov (+7)
3-Cossa (+1)
4-Danielson (-3)
5-Augustine (+1)
6-MBN (-1)
7-Lombardi (+4)
8-Soderblom (new)
9-Plante (new)
10-Finnie (new)

Kasper Johansson graduated

Mazur wallinder drop out of top 10

 

[Fil Larkmanthanasiou]

When do we start the mid season prospect ranking poll?

 

[OldnotDeadWings]

Top 20

1.. ASP
2, Danielson
3. Cossa/Augustine
5. MBN
6. Buchelniikov
7. Mazur
8. Plante
9.. Lombardi
10. Finnie
11, N. Dower-Nilsson
12. Kiiskinen
13. Buium
14..Johansson
15. Soderblom
16, James
17. Wallinder
18. Tuomisto
19. Savage
20. Gylander