Toggle sidebar

Proposal: Poll: Will Smith or trade 5th overall for Clayton Keller?

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates

Will Smith or trade 5th overall for Clayton Keller?

  • Will Smith

    Votes: 178 66.4%

  • Clayton Keller

    Votes: 90 33.6%
  • Total voters
    268
  • Poll closed .
Destopcorner said:
But we have a 24yo PPG star ? Braindead comment lol crawl back to your hole.
Click to expand...
I wasnt aiming the brainlet picture at you, just thought it'd be a funny way to describe the feeling of letting Keller walk after 5 years of first line production without nothing to show for besides a trade in which we gave a younger version of him, or better.
 
Tough one. Keller’s age (24), position (PPG winger) and contract terms (7.15M AAV with 5 years left) could actually fit the Habs’ rebuilding strategy.

But pulling the trigger at the expense of a cost-controlled C - and taking the risk of Keller hitting UFA-status during an emerging contender window - could prove perilous on its own.

Overall, it’s worth it if the Habs think they can start competing within 2-3 years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Troyp
ML16 said:
Tough one. Keller’s age (24), position (PPG winger) and contract terms (7.15M AAV with 5 years left) could actually fit the Habs’ rebuilding strategy.

But pulling the trigger at the expense of a cost-controlled C - and taking the risk of Keller hitting UFA-status during an emerging contender window - could prove perilous on its own.

Overall, it’s worth it if the Habs think they can start competing within 2-3 years.
Click to expand...
Habs are not a 5 year plan now, they are a 2 year plan now to make the playoffs.
they are paying their top forwards 7 plus, its time build around with talent

guy like Keller is just that
 
  • Like
Reactions: JohnTheBaptist and MrNasty
Absolutely. And we would be crazy not to do this if Michkov is gone at 5. He would be our biggest point getter, 86 points last year on a shit team.

Dubois - Suzuki - Caufield
Slafkovsky - Dach - Keller

We could win the cup with this top 6 in as little as 2 more seasons.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 26Mats
I would seriously consider this : 5OV + Gally for keller. Arizona need to take a big contract.

The real question is the rebuild finish? We have the potential to finish in the bottom 5/10 next year. Another high first round player could be useful for the tank....
 
  • Like
  • Wow
Reactions: 26Mats and jaffy27
Nico Cauzuki said:
and what exactly are you guys hoping to get Keller for ? we're not getting Clayton for a bunch of B prospects hes a better player then Suzuki and Caufield so think about the return u would want for our 2 players and then add theres no way u get a chance at him unless u start with one of Suzuki,Caufield,Dach,Slafkovsky or #5


chances our player at 5 is better then Keller is very small ( unless we pick Michkov ) and hes under contract for another 5 years @ 7.15 thats an amazing contract so no i doubt will get better value with our pick
Click to expand...
I don’t know what Arz wants but if he wants out and the Habs can package something outside of the core (Suzuki, Caufield, #5, Dach, Etc..) then great. Otherwise, their is no point; specifically because Keller seems to want out.
 
rahad said:
I would seriously consider this : 5OV + Gally for keller. Arizona need to take a big contract.

The real question is the rebuild finish? We have the potential to finish in the bottom 5/10 next year. Another high first round player could be useful for the tank....
Click to expand...
That's what I would like least about getting Keller for #5: makes our pick worse next year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rahad
sampollock said:
Habs are not a 5 year plan now, they are a 2 year plan now to make the playoffs.
they are paying their top forwards 7 plus, its time build around with talent

guy like Keller is just that
Click to expand...
The ticker doesn’t start until guys like Suzuki and Caufield are in their prime and that’s still a few years away. We still have a lot of work to put it lightly when it comes to keeping pucks out of our net.
 
I really don't want will smith lmao. His offence looks incredible but I don't like all the other stuff. Idk if id trade him for Keller though

I want michkov and if not him I'll gladly take Leonard.
 
rahad said:
I would seriously consider this : 5OV + Gally for keller. Arizona need to take a big contract.

The real question is the rebuild finish? We have the potential to finish in the bottom 5/10 next year. Another high first round player could be useful for the tank....
Click to expand...
Gally has a no trade clause. And yes the rebuild would be completely finished. We could make the playoffs next year.
 
Vachon23 said:
We won't money to sign them all, I prefer keeping Smith and put money elsewhere.

They are no special recipe to build a winning team (except that you need at least a #1C and #1D). We won't have a franchise player to build around, so if we want to win, we will need a super complete team with no major hole.
Click to expand...
Could have a franchise player. Just draft michkov.
 
  • Like
Reactions: xposbrad
Potentially an 80+ point player available, I expect 180+ pages of discussion... :sarcasm:
 
26Mats said:
Cooley > Keller?


Smith may well turn out to be a Keller. But that's far from assured.


I think there will be room for both. Hoffman comes off the books next summer and Armia's last year can be moved. Also, maybe Armia is part of the deal for Keller to equilibrate salaries.

Also, when's the last time an American wanted out? Petry was due to covid. Was it Rod Langway???
Click to expand...
I'll take my chances. Smith going to be hell of a player
 
This team "worked" so hard this season to get that 5th OA and now you want to trade it away?

Why would you bother tanking an entire season, if the prize was going to be Keller? :huh:
 
My main concern with Keller is the term. You only get 5 years. And out of those 5 years, only 3-4 pretty much matter cause the Habs won't be competing for the next 1-2 years. He's American and will be seeking the most amount of money possible at ufa so it's likely be doesn't resign unless you throw crap loads of money at a guy close to 30. So essentially you're giving up at the very least 7-8 years of a player who may be as if not more effective than Keller for realistically 3-4 years. Habs have a super young core, realistically their window is probably 2025-2033.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Andrei79
ML16 said:
Tough one. Keller’s age (24), position (PPG winger) and contract terms (7.15M AAV with 5 years left) could actually fit the Habs’ rebuilding strategy.

But pulling the trigger at the expense of a cost-controlled C - and taking the risk of Keller hitting UFA-status during an emerging contender window - could prove perilous on its own.

Overall, it’s worth it if the Habs think they can start competing within 2-3 years.
Click to expand...
1. Smith likely won’t make it to 5th
2. Smith is not a sure-fire center, winger is just as likely at nhl level. Lots of playmaking wingers bust btw
 
Keller is no slush, the guy is driving offense on his own, 36 goals on a weak teams, nearly 90 points. Sure Smith have potentiel and his younger, but we already have a young core and promising prospects, Keller would elevate our player, hes small but he keep his heads up, anyway it will not happen but i would not be mad if im wrong
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom