Players that completely checked out after getting paid

  • We sincerely apologize for the extended downtime. Our hosting provider, XenForo Cloud, encountered a major issue with their backup system, which unfortunately resulted in the loss of some critical data from the past year.

    What This Means for You:

    • If you created an account after March 2024, it no longer exists. You will need to sign up again to access the forum.
    • If you registered before March 2024 but changed your email, username, or password in the past year, those changes were lost. You’ll need to update your account details manually once you're logged in.
    • Threads and posts created within the last year have been restored.

    Our team is working with Xenforo Cloud to recover data using backups, sitemaps, and other available resources. We know this is frustrating, and we deeply regret the impact on our community. We are taking steps with Xenforo Cloud to ensure this never happens again. This is work in progress. Thank you for your patience and support as we work through this.

    In the meantime, feel free to join our Discord Server
Taylor Hall with Buffalo.

Hall clearly never wanted to play for the Sabres. But they offered a big money deal for one year, and he knew he'd get traded to a contender at the deadline. So he took the money (8 million, he never got over 6 any other year in his career) and totally checked out.

37 games played. 2 goals. 17 assists. Hall looked like garbage and contributed nothing while the team hit the league's all-time longest losing streak. He checked out harder than any player I've ever seen.

You can tell it wasn't just that he got too old or had a decline, because he picked it back up after he was traded. 14 points in 16 games with Boston.
I dunno, he only played 37 games for them and he managed to outscore Sabres legend Taro Tsujimoto by two goals, so that's kind of impressive.

I jest; Taylor Hall's Buffalo stint is posterchild for this thread. Some fun stats from that miserable half-season: Hall scores a goal in his first game (a 6-4 loss to Washington). He'd score just one goal in the next 36 games before getting traded. He actually had a promising start in Buffalo, with 6 points in his first three games. That means he had just 11 in his next 34.

When he got traded to the Bruins mid-season, his first game as a Bruin was against the Sabres. That gave Hall the opportunity to match or pass his Buffalo goal total against them, in one game. That would have been an all-time hilarious stat but of course he ruins it and goes pointless instead. But Hall did play against the Sabres 4 more times, finishing the season with 5 points in 5 games (1 goal and 4 assists) against Buffalo. Roughly double his per-game production against the team that was paying him.

Speaking of paying him, Buffalo paid Hall $8 million dollars with a $1 million dollar signing bonus for him to shoot 2.3% for them. For reference, the lowest career shooting percentage in NHL history (I'm assuming with some sort of minimum games threshold) is Bert Marshall's* 1.5%. Hall's 2.3% would rank third lowest if he'd done that over his career. Hall's career SH% is 10.3. Hall's 2.3SH% was the lowest of any of the 26 Buffalo Sabres to score a goal that year.

Hall scored points in 5 Sabres wins over the course of his time there. He had zero goals in Buffalo wins.

Last bit of weirdness: Both of Hall's goals during his time in blue and gold were in road losses against goalies named Ilya (Sorokin and Samsonov). Basically, if you wanted to shut out Hall that year, start anyone not named Ilya and you were golden.

That's it for now. Far more effort than that absolute all-time trash tier half-season by Hall was worth but hopefully you got some amusement out of it.

*No shade on Bert Marshall, he stuck around for close to 1000 games and he wasn't there for his offence. He was a rugged stay-at-home type defenseman in the 60s and 70s.

Also not too sure what happened here. Not quite the Taylor Hall I remember...
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_26-3-2025_16216_www.bing.com.jpeg
    Screenshot_26-3-2025_16216_www.bing.com.jpeg
    67.6 KB · Views: 3
Last edited:
John Gibson hasn't had a season better than .904% since his contract started. He gives zero Fs.
Whoa, watch it there! I got absolutely torched for saying he’s not a good goalie anymore and pointing out his last good season was in 2017/2018.

Maybe people are starting to realize but the notion he’d get traded to a contender and be an elite goalie again IMO is wrong.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Slaydagnar
Jeff Skinner?

Not even close.

He got lucky and found some magic as Eichel’s trigger man. High shooting percentage as well. Then he had a new coach, Eichel got traded, he was relegated to 4th line, and then he simply grew older.

This is the definition of stat watching and ignoring the actual context behind why guys have career years. He actually put up more points in ‘22-‘23 with Tuch and Thompson, who themselves found magic for a short while, but I guess you ain’t even watching the stats too closely. Mercurial offense-only player, sure, but dude cares.
 
Only guy Im really familiar with here.

Seto had issues with alcohol and was traded before ever playing a game for SJ after signing his contract. The guy seemed pretty depressed. Hopefully hes happy and healthy post NHL

Depression seems like a pretty likely reason for "checking out" so there's that.
 
Not even close.

He got lucky and found some magic as Eichel’s trigger man. High shooting percentage as well. Then he had a new coach, Eichel got traded, he was relegated to 4th line, and then he simply grew older.

This is the definition of stat watching and ignoring the actual context behind why guys have career years. He actually put up more points in ‘22-‘23 with Tuch and Thompson, who themselves found magic for a short while, but I guess you ain’t even watching the stats too closely. Mercurial offense-only player, sure, but dude cares.
Is that you Jeff? Holy taking it personal buddy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TS Quint
Seeing a few Huby posts and they are off the mark. He’s been a decent defensive presence (plays the pk) and has legitimately changed his game even though the team doesn’t systematically play to his strengths. 65-70 pts isn’t great for a player his caliber, but he isn’t a guy who has “checked out” by any means

What are you talking about?? Huberdeau has only been over 70 points, three (3) times in his career. Let's not pretend that his 115 point season is normal.
 
What are you talking about?? Huberdeau has only been over 70 points, three (3) times in his career. Let's not pretend that his 115 point season is normal.
4 seasons in a row he was well above a point per game, not sure what you're trying to say with this.
 
Huberdeau isn’t worth his contract, but he’s not checked out. He leads his team in scoring and has bought into the grinding-type game the Flames play even though it isn’t his style at all. The guy tries. He’s just not a great fit in that system.
It’s more than just not fitting into a system, because that would suggest that in a better fitting environment that he’s be a 90-100 or more point player again.

He’s declined and checked out too much to reach that level again.
 
Or you had a bad take worthy of evisceration. It’s just kinda the embodiment of the ignorant number watching I despise, all offense.
Because I asked a question?

Dude was thrown into a garbage organization, had 1 good offensive season, still awful defensively, was thrown $2-3M more than he deserved AAV wise, took it wisely, and couldnt replicate that season for 2 years, only to be bought out still deservingly so.

I think he was a a huge catalyst in the bad culture in Buffalo and you seem to blame coaches only. If you think the effort was there still in his down seasons, then ok, but I disagree, and think he only tried when it was convenient for his game.
 
What are some examples of players that were never the same after getting a big long term contract ?

Rick DiPietro ?

Is Pettersson trending in that direction right now ?
I don't think DiPietro fits here actually. He played the best hockey of his career after he signed his deal, before the injuries hit. As soon as those hips started to go though, he was cooked. Injuries completely derailed his career.
 
Dustin Penner.
He just wasn't good enough for what he was being paid. I don't think he ever was an intense player, and when Edmonton gave him that ungodly offer sheet, he took it, but he wasn't any lazier than he was before. He was just mis-judged by the Oilers, who brought him in to be a leader, when he was clearly a role player with good physical tools, but without the tools to be a locker room leader. I'm not sure if "checked out" is right for Penner either.
 

Ad

Ad