OT: Pirates Talk: Lets Play Ball

Mike Rabelo has never made a good decision in his life, and/or Bart has no business deciding to run there. Hernandez is not a good defender but he had a running start and was over halfway to the infield by the time he caught it.

Especially with Sasaki's wildness, there's no need to try and force that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ImporterExporter
Yeah, those are the types of scenarios where I am not willing to waive the "Shelton has a terrible roster due to Cherington" flag.

He is extraordinarily stubborn with needing to use his guys. There is no reason on earth for Holderman to face Hernandez in his first game back. At bare minimum, he needs to pitch a non-leverage spot and have a clean couple of innings first. But tonight, Santana should be available, and you have to play to win this game.

Holderman probably singlehandedly lost it, and we are likely getting our faces stomped in with Glasnow vs Falter tomorrow.
 
Shelton allowing Holderman to pitch is a disaster. To be honest, Holderman being in the ML roster is a disaster. The guy is not good.
 
Apparently he said after the game that Santana was down, but Santana threw 3 pitches in game 1 vs LAA, 17 in game 2, off day for game 3, and threw 11 on Friday night. I'm sure they have various internal things for resting players, but the math isn't really adding up, especially since Bednar had thrown more pitches in the same games, and though Shelton also mentioned Bednar in his postgame comments, Bednar was warming up in the pen.

Regardless, it's probably better for the anti-front office sentiment and narrative if we have series W vs bad team / Skenes masterclass against Dodgers' 1a/1b ace and then immediate series loss to undercut any possible momentum.

I do have to imagine that something will be done soon, but who knows. Mlod back to the pen and Bubba as 5th starter seems like the easy button to press, though Bubba may not initially be good for a ton more innings than Mlod. I think he's really legit, but IMO there's bound to be some skewed perception with rookie pitching debuts given both Skenes' freakishness as well as how good Jones was all year (even if he maybe tapered towards the latter part of the season). It's still well within the cards that we push the easy button but Bubba comes up and is too wild or has trouble adjusting immediately.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BusinessGoose
Apparently he said after the game that Santana was down, but Santana threw 3 pitches in game 1 vs LAA, 17 in game 2, off day for game 3, and threw 11 on Friday night. I'm sure they have various internal things for resting players, but the math isn't really adding up, especially since Bednar had thrown more pitches in the same games, and though Shelton also mentioned Bednar in his postgame comments, Bednar was warming up in the pen.

Regardless, it's probably better for the anti-front office sentiment and narrative if we have series W vs bad team / Skenes masterclass against Dodgers' 1a/1b ace and then immediate series loss to undercut any possible momentum.

I do have to imagine that something will be done soon, but who knows. Mlod back to the pen and Bubba as 5th starter seems like the easy button to press, though Bubba may not initially be good for a ton more innings than Mlod. I think he's really legit, but IMO there's bound to be some skewed perception with rookie pitching debuts given both Skenes' freakishness as well as how good Jones was all year (even if he maybe tapered towards the latter part of the season). It's still well within the cards that we push the easy button but Bubba comes up and is too wild or has trouble adjusting immediately.

Barco hasn't allowed an earned run all year in Altoona. I would consider having him skip AAA altogether in addition to bringing Chandler up
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Ad

Ad