This is fair and I am guilty of it. It’s hard for me to reconcile just how much he declined after his first five seasons and I don’t think I ever really got over it. Realistically, he’s been pretty good in the fifteen years since he stopped being one of the five greatest players to make their debut between 1967-2010, but it would be so much easier to cheer this on if he didn’t stop posting 100 point seasons after age 24, and crumbled from a 110-120 point caliber player of the time to someone struggling to stay around a PPG.
To be fair, post-peak Ovi lined up directly with the dead puck era 2.0.
2011: Down year, but 7th in points. Realistically equivalent to ~105 points today.
2012: Worst year of his career. But 5th in goals and 37th in points was equivalent to 49 goals and 75 points last year.
2013: Low scoring + half season. But he had the best season in the NHL that year (even if Crosby was a better player and just missed games). But that season definitely is equivalent to 55-60 goals + 110-120 points based on the last few years.
2014: 1st in goals and 8th in points, with that goalscoring year being one of the most dominant of all time. Pretty close to a 60-65 goal, 105 point season today.
2015: Best season by a non-goalie. Crazy dominant goal year, 4th in points and not that far behind 1st. Pretty close to a 60-65 goal, 115-120 point season today.
From 2011-2017 (7 seasons, there were only 5x 100 point seasons because of how low scoring the league was). The last few years we are averaging like 9x per season!