Proposal: Ottawa and Buffalo

[KevinRedkey]

To BUF:
D.Batherson - 4.975 (2+ years left)
J.Bernard-Docker - 0.805 (RFA)

To OTT:
JJ.Peterka - 0.855 (RFA)

Any tweaks needed?

Edit:
First 4 replies were made before I edited the post (see post #5)

Click to read more...

 

[The Devilish Buffoon]

Seems extremely good for Ottawa, don't see the appeal for Buffalo

 

[Beerz]

To BUF:
D.Batherson - 4.975 (2+ years left)
A.Gaudette - 0.775 (UFA)
J.Bernard-Docker - 0.805 (RFA)

To OTT:
JJ.Peterka - 0.855 (RFA)
J.Zucker - 5.000 (UFA)

Any tweaks needed?

Nope.

 

[truthbluth]

To BUF:
D.Batherson - 4.975 (2+ years left)
A.Gaudette - 0.775 (UFA)
J.Bernard-Docker - 0.805 (RFA)

To OTT:
JJ.Peterka - 0.855 (RFA)
J.Zucker - 5.000 (UFA)

Any tweaks needed?

Yup, take out Peterka completely. Tweaked.

 

[KevinRedkey]

Seems extremely good for Ottawa, don't see the appeal for Buffalo

I didn't realize Zucker was having such a good year. I misread his stat line (was looking at Jack Quinn's I think).

I'll remove him and Gaudette and reflect it in the OP.

My bad.

 

[Sanderson]

Don't really see the point for Buffalo.

Batherson and Peterka have similar numbers right now, but Peterka is 3-4 years younger with more room to grow. Neither is particularly physical, so it's not like Batherson would offer Buffalo a different component.
Bernard-Docker is a depth defenseman who makes no real difference.

I can see why Ottawa would think about it (trying to rekindle the Stützle-Peterka connection from German international games), but it's not like it would be a guaranteed improvement for them either.

Seems more like a change of scenery deal for players of a similar level, but neither is really in need of a change of scenery, Peterka even less so than Batherson.

 

[SnS]

I didn't realize Zucker was having such a good year. I misread his stat line (was looking at Jack Quinn's I think).

I'll remove him and Gaudette and reflect it in the OP.

My bad.

I don’t think the problem was Zucker.

I don’t think they would trade JJ.

 

[Duddy]

Not saying they are going to, but Sabres trades should only be packages for better players, no more moving sideways (this trade) or backwards (picks and prospects).

 

[The Devilish Buffoon]

I didn't realize Zucker was having such a good year. I misread his stat line (was looking at Jack Quinn's I think).

I'll remove him and Gaudette and reflect it in the OP.

My bad.

I still don't see why Buffalo moves Peterka for Batherson, though, and JBD is worth a 4th or 5th to the right team (which I don't think would be Buffalo), so I don't think he moves the needle at all

Greenway would be a nice add in the offseason or via trade + extension; Zucker, too, but I think he will stay in the States.

 

[Adele Dazeem]

Ottawa could've had JJ, they instead opted to big brained and take Jarventie.
Sucks to suck.

 

[GCK]

Peterka isn’t being moved. Jack Quinn should be the target. Quinn has had similar progression to Greig who is a centre which is a position of need for Buffalo. I think Ottawa would need to add a pick to make up for draft pedigree 8OA vs 28OA in 2020.

 

[StoneHoffs129]

Peterka isn’t being moved. Jack Quinn should be the target. Quinn has had similar progression to Greig who is a centre which is a position of need for Buffalo. I think Ottawa would need to add a pick to make up for draft pedigree 8OA vs 28OA in 2020.

Center is more important then draft position buffalo adds, that being said greig isn't being moved.

 

[Djp]

To BUF:
D.Batherson - 4.975 (2+ years left)
J.Bernard-Docker - 0.805 (RFA)

To OTT:
JJ.Peterka - 0.855 (RFA)

Any tweaks needed?

Edit:
First 4 replies were made before I edited the post (see post #5)

Bathers on will be 27 to start next year and 2 yrs left

Peterka ends his ELC and
Is 23 to start next season

JBD is a bottom pair small size RD

If I'm trading Peterka to ottawa I'm getting back either Tkavhuk or Sanderson as part of a larger trade