Icebreakers
Registered User
- Apr 29, 2011
- 9,533
- 4,647
This is basically Zetterlund and a 4th for a 2nd. Everyone else arent nhl players. So Zetterlund moves you up 2 rounds lol.
Ostapchuk has more value than that 2nd rounder so that’s quite confusing to read.
So instead they trade for another young player who, if works out, will need a contract at the exact same time and, with the cap going up, will probably demand more than what Zetterlund is asking for now?They were talking extension with him, so it isn't just for next year and they wanted to keep him at a certain price. If they signed him to a 6-8 year deal and overpaid him, in 3-4 years when Celebrini, Eklund and Smith etc. get paid, all of the sudden Sharks fans are gonna complain that they would have cap space to add x, y and z if Grier didn't sign Zetterlund to that stupid contract.
Look, I'm still salty about the trade, but try to understand the logic and not just poke incorrect holes in it from an upset place. Grier (taken at his word) thinks this kid may be the big, strong, mean 3C that we don't have, like a purer 3C version of Wennberg scoring 0.5ppg, killing penalties, being a menace. And that player is vastly different than Zetterlund in 3 years, who is 28 and not likely all of a sudden a 3rd line menace but almost certainly scoring fewer points than he is today, or being an underwhelming scoring winger if we're honestly trying to build a contender. Ostapchuk has the chance to be the 3C that Grier has been trying to find (Bystedt, Edstrom, Lund, etc).So instead they trade for another young player who, if works out, will need a contract at the exact same time and, with the cap going up, will probably demand more than what Zetterlund is asking for now?
They are already complaining about the Goodrow contract which should be off the books before any of our young guys need a raise.They were talking extension with him, so it isn't just for next year and they wanted to keep him at a certain price. If they signed him to a 6-8 year deal and overpaid him, in 3-4 years when Celebrini, Eklund and Smith etc. get paid, all of the sudden Sharks fans are gonna complain that they would have cap space to add x, y and z if Grier didn't sign Zetterlund to that stupid contract.
I appreciate that side of the analysis. I only mean if he priced himself out of SJ, who knows what will happen with a cap strapped team.
Still, that's the GM's problem.
Did he not say in his presser “this is the last time we’re going to ship guys out”?Look, I'm still salty about the trade, but try to understand the logic and not just poke incorrect holes in it from an upset place. Grier (taken at his word) thinks this kid may be the big, strong, mean 3C that we don't have, like a purer 3C version of Wennberg scoring 0.5ppg, killing penalties, being a menace. And that player is vastly different than Zetterlund in 3 years, who is 28 and not likely all of a sudden a 3rd line menace but almost certainly scoring fewer points than he is today, or being an underwhelming scoring winger if we're honestly trying to build a contender. Ostapchuk has the chance to be the 3C that Grier has been trying to find (Bystedt, Edstrom, Lund, etc).
Thank you for the detailed report on him! Funny you mentioned Adam Lowry as Grier in his media availability compared Ostapchuk to an Adam Lowry type of player.For Sharks fans wanting some information on Ostapchuk:
Ostapchuk is a good player and he’s very projectable. He’s big, great skater, plays with pace, hits and has grit, willing to fight … and he has some offensive instincts. Do not look at his stat line from this year in the NHL and be dissapointed. He played this year, probably before he was completely ready, because of injuries. He was also playing on the 4th line with players who don’t create offense. After that he played for a bit on the 3rd line with tough matchups, tough thing to do for a guy in his first year.
I think a realistic projection for Ostapchuk is a match-up 3rd line checking center who can put up 30-35 points and probably a bit more in his peak. That’s extremely valuable in today’s NHL. He will 100% be a very good NHLer. There’s no doubt about it. He’s very responsible defensively so what he needs to work on is his confidence to make things happen offensively. He’ll probably be playing at 215ish in his mid 20s.
The only reason Sens traded him is really because they have the depth at center with Stutzle, Cozens, Pinto, Greig and etc. Otherwise I guarantee you Sens would have kept him and molded him for that 3rd line role.
Ostapchuk will be a fan favourite in San Jose. Just be patient with him. He will be a heart and soul guy for you for years to come and will bring a lot of value. Think someone like Adam Lowry.
Thank you for the detailed report on him! Funny you mentioned Adam Lowry as Grier in his media availability compared Ostapchuk to an Adam Lowry type of player.
I'm not saying I agree with his decision, but every GM has a limit to what they're willing to pay each player. It happened with Rantanen and Marchand and apparently Zetterlund. It also affects what other players on your team are going to expect on their next deal too. If Zetterlund wants 6M, how do you say no if Eklund wants 8 or 9?So instead they trade for another young player who, if works out, will need a contract at the exact same time and, with the cap going up, will probably demand more than what Zetterlund is asking for now?
Full rebuilds take 6 to 7 years unless you get really lucky or have no State income tax.He's 25. This is basically Grier saying he doesn't intend on competing until 2030
The hawks traded Hagel to kick off a long term rebuild plan. This is mid rebuild selling a valid future piece away. The timing is way differentI don‘t think this was a good idea for the Sharks.
It‘s like Hawks and Hagel all over again.
The hawks traded Hagel to kick off a long term rebuild plan. This is mid rebuild selling a valid future piece away. The timing is way different
Staois said this deal doesn't happen if they don't make the Cozens trade. Makes me like the Cozens deal even more because that 2nd rounder made this other pick expendable.
Especially when you add that we recently lost other big strong centers with potential like Paul and kastelic. But you gotta do what you gotta do. Still have HallidayQuite sad to lose Ostapchuk tbh.
Loved him as a prospect since his days in junior
A lot of San Jose's good players are smaller players.Like this a lot for Ottawa. San Jose is tanking too hard too uneccesarily. They’re at risk of delaying meaningful contention under Celebrini too long. There hasn’t been a single successful dynasty that was just young players with veterans here and there as useless plugs. Chicago had guys like Sharp, Hossa, Keith and Campbell. Pittsburgh had Gonchar, Malone, Kunitz, Guerin, Orpik etc. Tampa was almost entirely in its prime.