Proposal: Other offers for PK Subban

[Oleg Petrov]

Now that we know what PK Subban was traded for, I would like to see proposals from other fan bases that in their opinion would have been a "better" deal for Montreal.

As a neutral living in Colorado, I think Colorado would have been willing to give up:

Rantanen and Barrie for Subban

I believe that to be a better package than Weber, but I'm a big Tyson Barrie fan.

Click to read more...

 

[Toby Flenderson]

Would have given Malkin+maatta for subban+Galchenyuk

 

[GUY 10]

I believe that the following deal with EDM would have been equitable for both teams

Hall
4OA
Klefbom
Yakupov

for
Subban
9OA

however, it is rumored that Bergevin insisted on Draisaitl instead of Hall, and RNH instead of Yak.

This stopped Chiarelli from pulling te trigger on the trade early. Wen Columbus dropped the bombshell of picking Dubois instead of Puljujarvi, everything fell apart.

 

[PuqTalk]

Vatanen (sign and trade on current deal), Ritchie, Montour, 1st, 3rd for Subban, Beaulieu

 

[Oleg Petrov]

Vatanen (sign and trade on current deal), Ritchie, Montour, 1st, 3rd for Subban, Beaulieu

That's a great package. Although scary term and dollars locked up in 4 players for Anaheim.

 

[kingdok]

Now that we know what PK Subban was traded for, I would like to see proposals from other fan bases that in their opinion would have been a "better" deal for Montreal.

As a neutral living in Colorado, I think Colorado would have been willing to give up:

Rantanen and Barrie for Subban

I believe that to be a better package than Weber, but I'm a big Tyson Barrie fan.

every time I see Subban and Barrie in the same sentence, I remember this:

 

[Reaper45]

Muzzin ++

 

[KrisLetAngry]

Pk subban + 2017 1st for letang

 

[MattMartin]

Edmonton
Fayne
Yak
Reinhart
Eberle

Montreal
Subban

 

[Canadian Canuck]

Tanev+5th OA for Subban+9th OA

 

[Moorpheus*]

Edmonton
Fayne
Yak
Reinhart
Eberle

Montreal
Subban

No rnh, deai, hall, klef or nurse......NO

 

[Oleg Petrov]

Tanev+5th OA for Subban+9th OA

I think it would have been Tanev & 5th OA for Subban. Straight, no additions.

 

[ThirdManIn]

It looks like a team would have to give up a top 15ish defenseman, preferably right handed. That severely limits the pool of teams who could have made a legitimate offer.

I saw something about Subban and a 1st for Letang. Letang's value is higher than Weber's currently, but the difference certainly isn't a first round pick. I doubt Montreal would have done that.

 

[kingdok]

Edmonton
Fayne
Yak
Reinhart
Eberle

Montreal
Subban

I keep Weber

 

[Mike Hasselhoffman]

Muzzin ++

If the ++ starts with a "T" and ends in an "Offoli" then I would have done that deal. Muzzin is a great defensemen, criminally underrated IMO.

Doubt LA would be able to take on Subban's contract without salary being sent back.

 

[Reaper45]

If the ++ starts with a "T" and ends in an "Offoli" then I would have done that deal. Muzzin is a great defensemen, criminally underrated IMO.

Doubt LA would be able to take on Subban's contract without salary being sent back.

Doubt it. The Kings would've needed to send salary back. Gaborik and a pick more likely.

 

[YP44]

I believe that the following deal with EDM would have been equitable for both teams

Hall
4OA
Klefbom
Yakupov

for
Subban
9OA

however, it is rumored that Bergevin insisted on Draisaitl instead of Hall, and RNH instead of Yak.

This stopped Chiarelli from pulling te trigger on the trade early. Wen Columbus dropped the bombshell of picking Dubois instead of Puljujarvi, everything fell apart.

too much from Edmonton IMO.

 

[TheGroceryStick]

Nylander
JvR
1st(2017)
2nd(31st)

 

[YP44]

Pk subban + 2017 1st for letang

Too much from Montreal and I love Letang

 

[Oleg Petrov]

Nylander
JvR
1st(2017)
2nd(31st)

The second coming in 2016?

 

[TheGroceryStick]

The second coming in 2016?

Yes. A edm fan offered 4oa. So I figured it was fair game to think in the past prior to the draft.

 

[Jared Dunn]

Edmonton
Fayne
Yak
Reinhart
Eberle

Montreal
Subban

How can you possibly think that's better value than Weber

 

[Jared Dunn]

Tanev+5th OA for Subban+9th OA

I like Tanev a lot but the difference between he and Subban is at the very least 5th overall, not jumping 4 spots in the draft... I'd have taken Tanev + Hutton + 5th OA for Subban + 2nd rounder

 

[Jumptheshark]

I believe that the following deal with EDM would have been equitable for both teams

Hall
4OA
Klefbom
Yakupov

for
Subban
9OA

however, it is rumored that Bergevin insisted on Draisaitl instead of Hall, and RNH instead of Yak.

This stopped Chiarelli from pulling te trigger on the trade early. Wen Columbus dropped the bombshell of picking Dubois instead of Puljujarvi, everything fell apart.

The ask was Nuge. 4th. Leon D. Nurse and somethnic else and montreal was not sending 9th

 

[McPhatty00]

As a Sabres fan, I know Subban to Buffalo would never have worked. If Edmonton was asking for Risto for Hall, Subban to Buffalo would've STARTED with Risto.