This is how I know yoU can't hold a conversation in french.
You can ask for basic services, and talk like a 3 year old, but no.. in french grammer is more important than vocabulary by a longshot.
Grammer > context > vocabulary, and then words sort of all sound jumbled and the same, and mishearing conjugation changes meanings completely.
I can read and write french pretty fluently, but there's no way I could actually converse here. The accent is incredibly thick. It's almost like trying to learn english from people with heavy Jamaican accents.
And I make videogames, so the ones here on Visa are programmers, artists, writers, engineers, designers .. (everyone has a degree).
The fact that you are so critical is something more deep-seated in you than a reflection of my ability in French or anything you actually know. Normally don't care about typos on HFOil, but it is relevant in a conversation about the basics of communicating in any language. The fact you sneered about my ability in French twice only to misspell grammar twice within the next sentence and a half is telling.
Thousands of hours of study absolutely gets you far more than the ability to babble like a child. Part of it is a commitment to try and speak French. How much popular culture consumed is in French? TV? Radio? Podcasts? Youtube videos? Movies? Those all help with the accent and understanding conversations at regular speak. You did talk about thousands of hours. A dedicated FSL student should commit hours listening to any of those in French. A dedicated hour a day listening to anything in French makes a big difference. Then have the student come back and test their listening ability. Even if someone only commits to doing that on weekdays it is a thousand hours over four years.
As to the professionals who can't get there in French. Some engineers are regulated professionals. The engineers might actually be professionals. If they have their P.Eng. The rest? White collar job =/= professional necessarily. Having a degree =/= being a professional.
7 weeks you don't know french. I know many people born and raised here who can't hold a conversation. They can 'get by' babbling like a 3 year old, but they're not considered 'french speakers'.
I didn't say I only studied for seven weeks. Just that I went to Montreal for the first time after seven weeks of my course and yes, could hold a basic conversation in French.
The accent in Montreal isn't that thick. Spend some time outside Montreal and you will get that.
If you can read and write "pretty fluently" you should be able to have a conversation. Especially the writing part. Writing at that level requires the ability to use correct grammar, in the appropriate context with relevant vocabulary at a relatively normal pace. If someone can do all those things before they write, then they should be able to say it out loud.
Babbling like a 3-year-old? Lol. A decent, reasonable person would never use that comparison for a few reasons. It is so demeaning and condescending it is really laughable. Certainly more of a defense mechanism than an actual appraisal of the situation.
Yes, there is a huge gap between babbling like a child and being considered a French speaker.
Shockingly it isn't a binary situation. It isn't you can only be a French speaker versus babbling like a 3-year-old. Just like a child doesn't automatically become a French speaker the transition for an adult learner isn't overnight either. That is where the commitment of time comes in.
I have seen many accomplished people who just give up when it comes to French. It is incredibly difficult to learn a language. But with thousands of hours it is possible.
This is a relevant example, but a little dated. When Sheila Fraser was Auditor General she proved to me that someone with no natural ability in the language could get there in French. Her accent was always brutal. But she spoke clearly and plainly in French and used proper grammar in doing so. She attained CCC in French despite not having any natural ability. She didn't give up and tell people she know they couldn't hold a conversation in French.