Confirmed with Link: OFFICIAL: Martin St-Louis is the 32nd head coach in Canadiens history (3 year contract)

dcyhabs

Registered User
May 30, 2008
4,456
2,678
Montreal
Well....I do. And from an outside perspective, it's probably the biggeset criticism I have with St. Louis. St. Louis is still a hockey player at heart. And after the practices, these little scrimmages he had with his assistants against players, having a lot of fun....I said not that long ago that I don't see how he'Ll suddenly go from that to you're fired.

He's having fun. He's comfortable. Why would he change that? My answer would be...to get a better bench. To help you as you are still a rookie coach. But that's clearly not how he sees it.
Well unlike when Bergevin, Therrien, Daigneault, and Lefebvre were all in their foxhole there isn't much pressure to win yet. As long as he feels the assistants are helping the players grow he doesn't have to care, yet, if they run the power play well or get the penalty kill working, or even set up a good system. You can do the stuff Bouchard talked about and put players in positions that aren't ideal to let them see what happens. In 2-4 years when there is pressure to win we'll see if MSL is still the guy and if he still wants the same assistants.
 

JianYang

Registered User
Sep 29, 2017
19,476
18,799
I mean, msl is saying all the right things about player development, but I don't know if that aligns with a 3 year deal.

It's actually a pretty short window, and it makes him vulnerable to become a firable scapegoat relatively quickly as the losses mount.

But I guess msl is okay with it, or else he didn't have to sign, but it just feels like he is talking about a long term vision without an appropriate contact length. Hopefully it doesn't force Marty to change his vision in an effort to stay on board.
 

Adam Michaels

Registered User
Jun 12, 2016
78,815
129,329
Montreal
I mean, msl is saying all the right things about player development, but I don't know if that aligns with a 3 year deal.

It's actually a pretty short window, and it makes him vulnerable to become a firable scapegoat relatively quickly as the losses mount.

But I guess msl is okay with it, or else he didn't have to sign, but it just feels like he is talking about a long term vision without an appropriate contact length. Hopefully it doesn't force Marty to change his vision in an effort to stay on board.

While we obviously focus on the players' development, we also need to remember MSL is also developing as a coach.

So when the Habs are ready to move to winning and be competitive, will MSL evolve to be the kind of coach who will coach to win and better run a bench?
 

Treb

Global Flanderator
May 31, 2011
29,692
30,478
Montreal




We've come a long way


Still flabbergasted he got a head coach job after the PIT debacle. I gave him the benefit of the doubt because I trusted in Bergevin (lol).

Not surprising he went jobless until his buddy Vigneault gave him a job. Hopefully this time he never pops up in any hockey related activity ever again. Unless it's the Leafs, then sure.
 

Kimota

ROY DU NORD!!!
Nov 4, 2005
40,030
15,206
Les Plaines D'Abraham




We've come a long way


I don't mind the hard ass coaches, personally. Always liked them when I played. I would love to know what was the situation in the second video, what game that was.

I think Serge Savard said it best though, when you hire coaches it's always for the need at present time. You hire a nice guy/pedagog(Perron) then the players become spoiled then you hire a hardass for a time to put some order(Burns), then a nice guy again(Demers) then a hardass(Tremblay), etc....

The biggest issue with the Therrien situation was that Bergevin didn't have the wisdom of a Serge Savard to realise that the Habs needed a change and he kept him too long. This lead to bad development and so forth.
 

WeThreeKings

Demidov is a HAB
Sep 19, 2006
95,514
106,847
Halifax




We've come a long way


The first f***ing clip boils my blood. Not only is he actually not coaching at all and can't explain what he wants them to do. PK remains very calm and professional, has a question about what Therrien is asking him to do and he just says "SKATE! MOVE THE PUCK"

Like.. that's the equivalent of me getting called in to do a presentation on Astrophysics. I know absolutely nothing so I would just be saying vague things like that.
 

Andy

Registered User
Jun 26, 2008
32,222
17,004
Montreal




We've come a long way

I am dying of laughter at the second video. Who is #40 that just stops walking and turns around when Therrien comes in the room? LMFAO

When you consider where the game was going (more speed and finesse), what skills the actual core had, Therrien was the worst possible coach the habs had at the time. It was such a terrible fit.
 

CaptainKirk

Registered User
Sep 27, 2004
1,528
3,279
Moncton
The first f***ing clip boils my blood. Not only is he actually not coaching at all and can't explain what he wants them to do. PK remains very calm and professional, has a question about what Therrien is asking him to do and he just says "SKATE! MOVE THE PUCK"

Like.. that's the equivalent of me getting called in to do a presentation on Astrophysics. I know absolutely nothing so I would just be saying vague things like that.
Student: “Do you feel that information can escape a black hole once it transforms from a hermit kingdom to a vigorously open system?”

WTK: “………… SKATE! MOVE THE PUCK"
 

Natey

GOATS
Sponsor
Aug 2, 2005
62,829
9,372
I am dying of laughter at the second video. Who is #40 that just stops walking and turns around when Therrien comes in the room? LMFAO

When you consider where the game was going (more speed and finesse), what skills the actual core had, Therrien was the worst possible coach the habs had at the time. It was such a terrible fit.
The only players who wore #40 under Therrien are Chouinard and Beaulieu. Considering the other players on the team, it's Beaulieu.
 

dcyhabs

Registered User
May 30, 2008
4,456
2,678
Montreal
I don't mind the hard ass coaches, personally. Always liked them when I played. I would love to know what was the situation in the second video, what game that was.

I think Serge Savard said it best though, when you hire coaches it's always for the need at present time. You hire a nice guy/pedagog(Perron) then the players become spoiled then you hire a hardass for a time to put some order(Burns), then a nice guy again(Demers) then a hardass(Tremblay), etc....

The biggest issue with the Therrien situation was that Bergevin didn't have the wisdom of a Serge Savard to realise that the Habs needed a change and he kept him too long. This lead to bad development and so forth.
You have to alternate coach types and MB hired only one type and that matched the previous guy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kimota

BehindTheTimes

Registered User
Jun 24, 2018
7,488
10,347




We've come a long way

I don’t know what’s worse, Michel Therrien’s coaching and piss poor attitude or the Habs brass thinking anything positive could come from allowing this to air. I just can’t believe they allowed this shit to go public. Wtf was this management doing? Jesus this is embarrassing, but we were too f***ing dumb to realize it?

Mickey Mouse.
 

HABitual Fan

Registered User
May 22, 2007
1,764
1,041
Well unlike when Bergevin, Therrien, Daigneault, and Lefebvre were all in their foxhole there isn't much pressure to win yet. As long as he feels the assistants are helping the players grow he doesn't have to care, yet, if they run the power play well or get the penalty kill working, or even set up a good system. You can do the stuff Bouchard talked about and put players in positions that aren't ideal to let them see what happens. In 2-4 years when there is pressure to win we'll see if MSL is still the guy and if he still wants the same assistants.
I know it probably would not have happened, but in a way I am sorry that we couldn't follow the Tampa coaching model. Promote Houle as the scapegoat for 3 years with the Habs, and have MSL develop the prospects in Laval, get to know them, gain coaching experience, and then get promoted like Cooper was to the NHL team.
 

Grate n Colorful Oz

The Hutson Hawk
Jun 12, 2007
36,327
34,643
Hockey Mecca
I'm still pissed that we wasted a core that had two terrific #1Ds and a future HOF goalie, by hiring some of the biggest morons in hockey management history.

Can you imagine that in Bergevin's tenure, the equivalent of a full cap's worth, about 80 million of the money we put in the team, through tickets, cable rights, concessions, merchandise and it was wasted on these morons.

I hope Molson learned his lessons well.
 

Tuggy

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Nov 26, 2003
49,751
16,942
Saint John
I remember when the lockout ended in 2013 being excited, but then I remembered Therrien was the coach and the excitement went away.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WeThreeKings

durojean

Registered User
May 29, 2007
2,373
1,345
For my part, I feel like there is nothing that bad about the video. It is true that you play like you practice and Therrien was really good to get the best out of players for a short amount of time.

He was really good to get guys to have a good work ethic and to read who was and who was not in his game.

He was really bad for developping talented kids and he was a little too tight on the structure he wanted the guys to play in. He also had a lot of favoritism for certain guy and that worked against him.

All in all, he got result from the guys and was a better coach than the 2 guy who came after him.
 

WeThreeKings

Demidov is a HAB
Sep 19, 2006
95,514
106,847
Halifax
For my part, I feel like there is nothing that bad about the video. It is true that you play like you practice and Therrien was really good to get the best out of players for a short amount of time.

He was really good to get guys to have a good work ethic and to read who was and who was not in his game.

He was really bad for developping talented kids and he was a little too tight on the structure he wanted the guys to play in. He also had a lot of favoritism for certain guy and that worked against him.

All in all, he got result from the guys and was a better coach than the 2 guy who came after him.

There's tons wrong with the video.

Do you have any idea of what he wants PK to do, other than practice like he plays? Cause it's extremely unclear what Therrien is asking from Subban. He just said skate and move the puck. Skate where, move the puck to who; when do I move the puck, is it after the first forechecker, before?

He couldn't communicate a god damn thing and instead just yelled at people.

At the end when PK, after being berated says "Coach, I have a question".. do you think Therrien gave a good response to that? Because he didn't give any additional information to PK.
 

Grate n Colorful Oz

The Hutson Hawk
Jun 12, 2007
36,327
34,643
Hockey Mecca
For my part, I feel like there is nothing that bad about the video. It is true that you play like you practice and Therrien was really good to get the best out of players for a short amount of time.

He was really good to get guys to have a good work ethic and to read who was and who was not in his game.

He was really bad for developping talented kids and he was a little too tight on the structure he wanted the guys to play in. He also had a lot of favoritism for certain guy and that worked against him.

All in all, he got result from the guys and was a better coach than the 2 guy who came after him.

Therrien was nothing more than a boot camp drill sargent.
 

Ad

Ad

Ad