It’s not about performance as you can look back & see mixed bags on that front with current NHLers. It’s simply being considered good enough to make the team. Take out guys who made the NHL in their D+1 &/or D+2. How many success stories of guys eligible in their post drafts years & not in the NHL that were passed up by their countries went on to have success in the NHL?
The best I can think of off the top of my head is Kyle Connor (which was a really controversial decision at the time) & Tyler Toffoli. USA Hockey ended up taking Connor to the WC’s later that year which in a way in an admission of a mistake. Both guys were prolific scorers at the NCAA & OHL levels those last year of eligibility years.
Other than that you’re mostly looking at goalies who probably make up most of your notable outliers.
Here’s all the players in their last year of eligibility for this tournament this year that are property of the Flyers:
- Samu Tuomaala
- Brian Zanetti
- Ty Murchinson
- Ethan Sampson
- Owen McLaughlin
- Alex Bump
- Alexis Gendron
Most of those guys weren’t even good enough to make the short lists for their countries. Toumaala & Sampson played some exhibition games with their countries before getting cut from the final roster. Murchinson, McLaughlin, Bump, & Gendron were never under any type of consideration by their countries. That leaves you Zanetti who’s not good & plays for a small country.