Yozhik v tumane
Registered User
- Jan 2, 2019
- 2,025
- 2,171
I was looking at Mark Messier's first season with the Rangers (1991-92) and kind of reviewing that club's year when I noticed a statistical oddity, which was Mess's plus/minus in The Rangers' 42nd game of the season (which was Mess's 41st), on January 4th, 1992 @ New Jersey. At Brendan Byrne Arena, the Devils won 6-4, and Messier was -6 for the game. The Devils scored 6 even strength goals and Mess was on the ice for every single one! Tony Amonte was also -6, so clearly that line had a rough night, but nobody else on the Rangers was worse than -3.
Mess himself was only worse than -2 in one other game that whole season (vs. Washington he went -3 one night), so that -6 is a real outlier. I checked his past with Edmonton, and only three times in twelve years did Mess go -4 in a single game with the Oilers. (Believe it or not, only once was he ever worse than -3 with the Canucks, which was a -4 game vs. Toronto in March 2000 and even then I think he was for the overtime goal against to go -4.)
In fact, I checked his entire career, that that -6 holds up as the single worst result. (Twice he went -5: once as a rookie with Edmonton, and once in the Rangers' 11-6 loss to Buffalo in that weird 1992-93 season.)
To be fair, -6 would be an outlier for most players, maybe even every player. Since +/- has been recorded, -7 or worse has only been recorded 24 times, and never for the same player twice. Bill Mikkelson, with the worst +/- season record, never had worse than -5 in a night, but the worst +/- game does belong to another player on the 1974-75 Capitals: Greg Joly went -9 in a game against Pittsburgh. Ouch.
This would be the most miserable minus game for an iconic line: Secord - Savard - Larmer all were -7 once against the 1984-85 Oilers. Oilers won the game in question 12-9, Savard had a goal and his wingers an assist each.
The only player to record -7 since Doug Wilson for the Sharks in 1993, was Calgary’s Chris Butler who did so in 2012 against the Bruins.
The last player to record -6 in a game was… drum roll… Victor Hedman! Just a few days ago, on December 30th 2021 in a 9-3 loss against the Panthers. Golly! Before this season, he’d only had worse than a -3 once in 2013-14 where he had a -5 vs. the Bruins, but this season Hedman’s been a -4 player twice in addition to his -6 game. What’s up with that?
Sources: Hockey-reference, Which Player Had Worst Plus Minus In One Game | StatMuse