What are you talking about dude?
A top prospect is worth 2 first round picks if they are a blue-chip prospect.
lol
Proposal: NYR trade for Miller (VAN) and Chychrun (ARZ)
- Thread starter Stephen Gionta
- Start date
What are you talking about dude?
A top prospect is worth 2 first round picks if they are a blue-chip prospect.
lol
You are delusional if you think there is a significant improvement. Like I said they are good players but not at the price being knocked around... Most of these deals being knocked around on this board are ridiculous. The initial proposal was basically two firsts and a second for JT, come on. If the situation were reveresed you would give up two firsts and a second for Jt. I thought not. Be realistic not a homer.
You don't think adding a top line forward and a top pairing defenseman is significant improvement?
Who do you want? Wayne Gretzky and a time machine?
If Rangers added Miller and Chycrun, they would be on par with Tampa.
Canucks say no to the original deal.
Take a look at some of the deadline days in the past and that's all I'll say. Did you see what Anthony Mantha and Blake Coleman got? Exactly.
Why are you bringing up Eichel? A healthy Eichel gets double his original package.
We still haven't seen him play yet. He could be a shadow of his former self.
Not remotely comparable...
Chycrun would be a second or possibly third pair dman .. he is not supplanting Lindgren or their pet project K. Miller. Your going to give up three firsts and other assets for a second or third pair Dman?
With a +/- of -31!
Miller like I said is a solid player but not at the asking price or salary.. Not to mention you have to negotiate another deal after next year. The Rangers have a bunch of players coming off entry contracts. Kakko, Laf, KAM, also Strome, Hunt, Blais , and Georgiev . They currently have approx 6 mil in cap space. Do you trade for him and let him walk after giving up basically two firsts and a second. Does his miserable personality fit in the locker room also.
With a +/- of -31!
Miller like I said is a solid player but not at the asking price or salary.. Not to mention you have to negotiate another deal after next year. The Rangers have a bunch of players coming off entry contracts. Kakko, Laf, KAM, also Strome, Hunt, Blais , and Georgiev . They currently have approx 6 mil in cap space. Do you trade for him and let him walk after giving up basically two firsts and a second. Does his miserable personality fit in the locker room also.
ole ole
Registered User
- Oct 7, 2017
- 11,999
- 6,088
It would be hard to not consider a Chychrun-Trouba as a 1st pairing
No. Not really. I’m by no means a Vancouver fan. But Lundkvist isn’t a top prospect. That’s why I assumed the 2nd was added.
Vancouver may get better offers than this but it seems pretty close. Given the second year of retention, maybe Rangers add a 2023 3rd for that.
I think both trades are close. They favor the NYRs but not so significantly they can’t be altered a little to make it dollar for dollar. Pretty good job by OP, whom I’m assuming is a rangers fan.
Last edited:
Haha you guys need to collectively go vote on where you are as a team lol.
Simultaneously we have posters saying they are first round exits at best, while others are saying the team is so good Chychrun would not be a top pairing defensman
Fitzy
Very Stable Genius
- Jan 29, 2009
- 35,724
- 23,008
He'd be a top pairing defenseman, he just wouldn't play on the pairing with Fox. He'd play with Trouba in all likelihood, and get the 2nd most minutes on defense.
