Value of: NYR & SJ

[Heckler81]

It appears that SJ is open to trading the #2 pick.

If NYR is willing to trade Fox to continue their rebuild and SJ offers the #2 pick.

What else would SJ have to include in prospects to make this an even trade?

 

[UnSandvich]

Sharks fans won't like the answer, and Fox isn't going to waive so it's a moot point.

 

[DJN21]

Everything fox has done throughout his career clearly points to him uprooting himself from his NYC penthouse to go rebuild across the country....

 

[Grinner]

I wouldn't give up the 2nd for Fox.
What more add to it

 

[miscs75]

June 25, 2026: Adam Fox traded to San Jose

June 26, 2026: Adam Fox announces retirement.

 

[lucky0slevin]

I wouldn't give up the 2nd overall for him and he doesn't want to leave NY case closed

 

[Grinner]

Sharks fans won't like the answer, and Fox isn't going to waive so it's a moot point.

You guys aren't still fantasizing about getting the 2ndoa and Misa for Fox....Are you?

 

[UnSandvich]

You guys aren't still fantasizing about getting the 2ndoa and Misa for Fox....Are you?

Not really, but that's closer than "less than the 2nd pick"

 

[Grinner]

Not really, but that's closer than "less than the 2nd pick"

Not in any realm

 

[WSS11]

Not really, but that's closer than "less than the 2nd pick"

Kind of like when some Rangers fans thought Panarin would return Misa. Fox has more value than Breadman but he isn’t returning either asset…especially with a NMC. It’s all moot though. He isn’t leaving NY

 

[UnSandvich]

Kind of like when some Rangers fans thought Panarin would return Misa. Fox has more value than Breadman but he isn’t returning either asset…especially with a NMC. It’s all moot though. He isn’t leaving NY

If there were people saying Panarin might fetch Misa as a pending UFA, I don't think they're worth giving the time of day to

 

[TheBeard]

Fox and Cuylle for 2

 

[Mattb124]

Sharks 2OA + a pick or prospect or two for Rag’s 5OA + Fox.

 

[Bizz]

any trade for 2 has gotta include your 5th OA or its a no deal

2nd OA + [whatever the hell else you want that's not Macklin, Smith, Misa, Chernyshov or Dickinson]
5OA + Fox

 

[GhostfaceWu]

Kind of like when some Rangers fans thought Panarin would return Misa. Fox has more value than Breadman but he isn’t returning either asset…especially with a NMC. It’s all moot though. He isn’t leaving NY

lol ya I don't buy that a single reasonable rangers fan ever said this. comparing a 34 year old ufa to a 28 year old in his prime with 3 years left at under ten million is certainly one way to make yourself disregarded just like those alleged ranger fans you referenced were disregarded by you.

 

[GhostfaceWu]

any trade for 2 has gotta include your 5th OA or its a no deal

2nd OA + [whatever the hell else you want that's not Macklin, Smith, Misa, Chernyshov or Dickinson]
5OA + Fox

lol at thinking the difference between 2 and 5 is a Norris winning dman that scores 70 points a season minimum when healthy.

 

[Bizz]

lol at thinking the difference between 2 and 5 is a Norris winning dman that scores 70 points a season minimum when healthy.

hence the [whatever the hell else you want that's not Macklin, Smith, Misa, Chernyshov or Dickinson]

 

[GhostfaceWu]

hence the [whatever the hell else you want that's not Macklin, Smith, Misa, Chernyshov or Dickinson]

yah you just listed every possible thing new york would want as being off limits. imagine thinking chernyshov is off limits for fox.

 

[ThePlanet]

Yeah, go ahead and keep Fox.

 

[UnSandvich]

Yeah, go ahead and keep Fox.

That's the plan, yeah.

 

[themelkman]

I like Fox but I dont know if I would deal number 2 for just two years of him at age 28. I wouldnt trust him to really negotiate in good faith for an extension either

 

[ThePlanet]

That's the plan, yeah.

Even if the rationale comes from polar opposite points, I'm glad we're on the same page

 

[Juxtaposer]

lol ya I don't buy that a single reasonable rangers fan ever said this. comparing a 34 year old ufa to a 28 year old in his prime with 3 years left at under ten million is certainly one way to make yourself disregarded just like those alleged ranger fans you referenced were disregarded by you.

The Rangers subforum was literally full of people suggesting Misa for Panarin around the trade deadline. Every time I searched “Misa” like 25% of the posts were from the Rangers’ subforum.

Speculation: Post in thread 'Roster/Trade Thread: Panarin being held out of line-up. (Sell, Sell, Sell, Edition)'

Jan 29, 2026

Misa is not anywhere within the realm of realistic lol you guys need to stop hyping this up

All it’s going to do is lead to disappointment

For Panarin, no. For Panarin and Schneider? I absolutely expect value at that level.

• Gardner McKay

• 

Speculation: Post in thread 'Roster/Trade Thread: Panarin being held out of line-up. (Sell, Sell, Sell, Edition)'

Jan 29, 2026

rangers trade:
panarin extended 11x4, rangers retaining 2.5m
schneider

rangers receive:
C michael misa
later of 2026 1st
D shakir mukhamadulin

Not enough if packaging both

• mrmovies779

• 

Friedman: Post in thread 'The Panarin Mega thread (All proposals here) - NYR to hold him out of the lineup throughout Olympic break'

Feb 1, 2026

To NYR:
2026 EDM 1st
2026 COL 2nd
2027 SJ 4th
Quentin Musty
Shakir Mukhamadullin
Philipp Kurashev

To SJ:
Artemi Panarin (4x12.5 extension)
Braden Schneider

Would the Rangers do this? Would Washington or Florida beat this offer (taking Schneider out of the equation)?

Rangers need more center depth. Misa would need to be included for a signed Panarin.

• RangersFan1994

• 

I could keep going.

 

[GhostfaceWu]

The Rangers subforum was literally full of people suggesting Misa for Panarin around the trade deadline. Every time I searched “Misa” like 25% of the posts were from the Rangers’ subforum.

Speculation: Post in thread 'Roster/Trade Thread: Panarin being held out of line-up. (Sell, Sell, Sell, Edition)'

Jan 29, 2026

Misa is not anywhere within the realm of realistic lol you guys need to stop hyping this up

All it’s going to do is lead to disappointment

For Panarin, no. For Panarin and Schneider? I absolutely expect value at that level.

• Gardner McKay

• 

Speculation: Post in thread 'Roster/Trade Thread: Panarin being held out of line-up. (Sell, Sell, Sell, Edition)'

Jan 29, 2026

rangers trade:
panarin extended 11x4, rangers retaining 2.5m
schneider

rangers receive:
C michael misa
later of 2026 1st
D shakir mukhamadulin

Not enough if packaging both

• mrmovies779

• 

Friedman: Post in thread 'The Panarin Mega thread (All proposals here) - NYR to hold him out of the lineup throughout Olympic break'

Feb 1, 2026

To NYR:
2026 EDM 1st
2026 COL 2nd
2027 SJ 4th
Quentin Musty
Shakir Mukhamadullin
Philipp Kurashev

To SJ:
Artemi Panarin (4x12.5 extension)
Braden Schneider

Would the Rangers do this? Would Washington or Florida beat this offer (taking Schneider out of the equation)?

Rangers need more center depth. Misa would need to be included for a signed Panarin.

• RangersFan1994

• 

I could keep going.

Wow a whole three examples. Did you miss the reasonable poster part of my post?

 

[Koivunsons]

2nd overall for Fox makes sense. Rangers are probably adding their pick from the Stars though.

If I was the Sharks, I'd try to do Will Smith + 20th overall for Fox though.

If that doesn't work I'd probably do Misa + for Fox.