Proposal: - NYI-DAL-UTA | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League

Proposal: NYI-DAL-UTA

EK392000

Registered User
Mar 9, 2020
1,149
1,656
Just as a base. Unsure if this has been covered before.

To NYI: 4th Overall Pick

To DAL: Noah Dobson

To UTA: Jason Robertson

UTA gets a PPG forward with a 100 point season under his belt, DAL gets a top pairing defenseman with a 70 point season under his belt, NYI gets Hagens.

Add as necessary to balance value.
 
Pretty good OP. Feel like perhaps NYI have to add something of substance.
 
Honestly depends on what direction Isles will want to go in but this can work.
 
Just as a base. Unsure if this has been covered before.

To NYI: 4th Overall Pick

To DAL: Noah Dobson

To UTA: Jason Robertson

UTA gets a PPG forward with a 100 point season under his belt, DAL gets a top pairing defenseman with a 70 point season under his belt, NYI gets Hagens.

Add as necessary to balance value.
Utah would be dumb to trade 4OA for a pkayer under contract just 2-= yrs
 
Utah would be dumb to trade 4OA for a pkayer under contract just 2-= yrs
Jason Robertson can sign an extension on July 1st so a deal would have to be worked on with an agreement to sign an extension on July 1, he’d have to wait a week or two.
 
Would Kesselring + 4th for Robertson be palatable? Just cut out the middleman.
 
Would Kesselring + 4th for Robertson be palatable? Just cut out the middleman.
I could see Dallas considering something like this if they wanted to preserve their depth. Kesselring would demand way less than Dobson which gives them flexibility to re-sign Granlund etc.
 
I fully understand.....

We have had other players who were RFA with 1- yr yo UFA who didn't return a yop t pick.
There would be due diligence beforehand to sort out an extension in this case (similar to Timo Meier).
 
Leave Utah out of the deal. Neither of those players are worth a top 5 pick. Even if it is a weaker draft, the top 4 guys are a better value to Utah.
Since 2017 how many guys drafted have a 100+ point seasons? Or are career PPG. GM drafting guys being in the top 5 would be thrilled if they got to Robertson’s level player. Both those guys are worth the 4th overall pick. Robertson is worth more.
 
Since 2017 how many guys drafted have a 100+ point seasons? Or are career PPG. GM drafting guys being in the top 5 would be thrilled if they got to Robertson’s level player. Both those guys are worth the 4th overall pick. Robertson is worth more.

Dallas should keep him then.
 
4ov alone is not enough to get you a 100pt winger or first pair Dman, you need a substantial add IMO
 
Leave Utah out of the deal. Neither of those players are worth a top 5 pick. Even if it is a weaker draft, the top 4 guys are a better value to Utah.
Dude it would be an absolute slam dunk if the 4ov end up as good as either player. It's the best case scenario.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

Ad

Ad