Nuck's Auction Draft Rules & Discussion

Should we have a waiver option before buyouts? Claiming team takes on full cap hit


  • Total voters
    13
  • Poll closed .

Nucker101

Foundational Poster
Apr 2, 2013
21,637
17,582
Round 1 Voting Results:

1721145521227.png

1721145549606.png

1721145591841.png

1721145653257.png

1721145676189.png

1721145765164.png

1721145847385.png

1721146073899.png

1721146320860.png

1721146538789.png


Notes
  • Please don't reveal which team you're GM of even if eliminated.
  • SEA vs TOR tied but we had a GM who hadn't voted yet settle the tiebreak, TOR advances​
  • VAN defeats WAS despite WAS receiving a slightly higher overall rating(3.0 vs 2.8) during pre-playoff polls​
  • VGK handedly defeats SJS despite SJS receiving a rating of 2.9 while VGK received a 2.8 rating​
  • WPG also a clear winner vs DAL despite both teams receiving a 2.9 rating​
  • As a reminder, these polls are for the 24-25 NHL season so I will rerun these polls after next season. So even if you believe your team got screwed during voting, the upcoming NHL season should separate the contenders from the pretenders​
  • R2 polls will be up shortly​
 

Nucker101

Foundational Poster
Apr 2, 2013
21,637
17,582
Round 2 Voting Results

Screenshot 2024-07-18 082455.png


Screenshot 2024-07-18 082530.png


Screenshot 2024-07-18 082546.png


Screenshot 2024-07-18 082600.png


Screenshot 2024-07-18 082614.png


Screenshot 2024-07-18 082627.png


Screenshot 2024-07-18 082810.png


Screenshot 2024-07-18 082754.png


Notes
  • EDM-MTL tiebreaker was settled by a GM who didn't vote, Montreal advances, he believed that MTL had a better overall forward and dman group and Demko wasn't enough to make up for it.​
  • WPG-NYR was a closer matchup than expected, NYR had a 3.5 rating and WPG sat at 2.9​
  • STL-NJD meanwhile was more lopsided than expected, STL had a 3.4 rating, NJD had a 3.2​
  • Please don't spoil your team yet even if you're out, otherwise voters can use process of elimination to figure out who's remaining, after we're done polls I'll post the full list of gm's with team names​
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Makaveli

Nucker101

Foundational Poster
Apr 2, 2013
21,637
17,582
Round 3 Polls are Live:


You have until midnight pacific time on friday to vote
 
Last edited:

Nucker101

Foundational Poster
Apr 2, 2013
21,637
17,582
R3 Results
Screenshot 2024-07-20 115452.png

Screenshot 2024-07-20 115441.png

Screenshot 2024-07-20 115428.png

Screenshot 2024-07-20 115357.png


Notes
  • 3/4 matchups were pretty decisive victories
  • For the semi finals we have:
  • NYR (consensus GM guess Trick) vs DET (consensus GM guess Beleafing)
  • LAK (consensus GM guess Panda) vs PHI (consensus GM guess Panda also)
 

Nucker101

Foundational Poster
Apr 2, 2013
21,637
17,582
Semifinal Results

semis.png


We once again had a tiebreak broken by a GM who didn't vote, PHI advances over LAK

Finals Poll:



Poll is live until Tuesday midnight PST, then on Wednesday I'll post the list of teams/gm's here so everyone can see who the shadow gm's were.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad