Value of: Noah Dobson, based on Sergachev Trade

[impaaaaaact]

No, going to hold onto Bolduc. I have a feeling the Blues are going to move Kyrou before his no trade kicks in July, and Bolduc has more scoring upside then Neighbors, however Neighbors is more of a complete player, 25 goal scorer who has also been talked about possible A - team leader type of player.
Now we could change the deal for Pavel Buchnevich, more of a proven goal scorer, then a lesser prospect that Jiricek.

the most realistic deal between these two teams is probably something around Kyrou and Dobson tbh. I think I'd rather keep Dobson at the end of the day though. Don't think Neighbors + Jiricek gets it done.

 

[Unbiased Fan]

From a leafs POV I’d offer Knies for Dobson.

 

[impaaaaaact]

From a leafs POV I’d offer Knies for Dobson.

That is…. Unexpected

 

[GhostfaceWu]

Don't see Dallas moving a defensive stud like Bischel for an OFD. They are have Heiskanen and Harley as puck movers.

Stud lol

 

[Bizz]

Sergachev is better than Dobson and can actually defend too.

 

[Dr Robot]

really would need a righty back if the young nil guy stepping up is a D, and I don't think Haltunnen is the correct caliber of prospect.


Would you sub Bolduc for Neighbors? not sure how you guys rank those two

I personally rate neighbors a good bit higher than Bolduc so id be fine if he was the piece. Some combination of Bolduc/Jiricek/this years first would be a reasonable basis on St. Louises end. Not sure the full package you guys are looking for.

 

[Kshahdoo]

Offensive defensemen are useful, but when they can't play defense, something like Carolina - Florida series happens. You need to play good defense to be successful in playoffs...

 

[rsteen]

I don't think Seattle would trade Shane Wright straight up for Dobson.

You also have to consider that Dobson's new contract is going to discourage a lot of buyers. L.A. for example would rather gamble on Clarke's development than fork over their cap flexibility for Dobson.

Seattle has Montour as well in that offensive RHD role so I can't see them going out to give up a lot of assets to acquire another one. Maybe if Dobson was younger/cheaper with a view to him replacing Montour when he got his big contract, but not right now.

 

[impaaaaaact]

I personally rate neighbors a good bit higher than Bolduc so id be fine if he was the piece. Some combination of Bolduc/Jiricek/this years first would be a reasonable basis on St. Louises end. Not sure the full package you guys are looking for.

I think something along the lines of Bolduc/Jiricek/2nd would do it, and I think most Isles fans would be on board. Not quite what Sergachev or Jones went for, but I could see it.

 

[Strickland]

I think something along the lines of Bolduc/Jiricek/2nd would do it, and I think most Isles fans would be on board. Not quite what Sergachev or Jones went for, but I could see it.

As an Isles fan, no thanks. If they can't do better than this, just hold onto Dobson.