expatriatedtexan
Habitual Line Stepper
- Aug 17, 2005
- 18,643
- 15,073
Do you think Girard's privacy was violated by being in the program any more than if he was granted a personal leave of absence to take care of personal business? The program didn't out anything about what he was suffering, he did that on his own. He was very open and honest about what was going on and what his goals were and I attribute that honesty and openness to his commitment to getting better.If being in the player assistance program brings more testing and scrutiny then players understandably will avoid it. The incentive structure just doesn’t favor a player entering it unless they are forced. Add in that a player will have their privacy violated by the program being very public and reaching out for help is made even more difficult. The solution is simple an increase in testing for all players and no additional penalties if you are in the player assistance program and get caught. It is completely the fault of Val but he isn’t the only player doing what he did in all likelihood.
Nuke on the other hand basically denied anything at all happened in the summer of '23. The team and the league never commented on drugs but we can assume that Nuke was whisked away to Stage 1. Then earlier this season he was ordered into Stage 2 and released a statement that it was to help with sleep deprivation due to his circadian rhythm being off...again with no mentions of drugs. Then he fails a drug test, goes into Stage 3 and hasn't made a peep.
I honestly believe the players here carry completely different labels if you want to call it that. One guy is obviously a recovering addict/abuser of alcohol and the other won't admit he has a drug problem although he's been confronted by it on several occasions. Without knowing the specifics, I can say that every treatment plan I've heard of is tailored to the individual. I wouldn't imagine that the frequency of random testing goes up after a player has entered any stage of the program, but I also would assume that it goes back down after a certain amount of time with no positive tests occurring. This is a trust but verify thing where the trust can actually be restored over time to the point where the verification is no longer needed. No matter what, I can't see Nuke's career lasting long enough. And while Girard might still be getting tested more frequently as his episode with this season, I think GMs are apt to trust him due to his openness and honesty.
My hope is that G's experience will help at least one person in the league who is suffering to get help. Even if it's a private program during the summer. But G is showing you can continue with your career. I know he gets a lot of grief on this board, but this was a bounce back season IMO.
I think you're right that players who don't really want help would rather go to a private program of their choosing so they can get an "easy" one as there are plenty that pamper their clients with luxury accommodations and activities while being less intrusive with their follow-on care. You basically graduate after the in-patient treatment and are done with the program.