I will never find it acceptable to wear the logo of a team you stole from another market, so the Avalanche and Hurricanes jerseys, while objectively the best-looking, immediately go to the bottom of the list for me. (I'd have been OK with a Whaler-style jersey with the Hurricanes logo, and the Avs should have thrown back to the Rockies; that at least was in-market.)
That said, I might as well rank them by tiers.
Tier 1: Wild (go to this colorway full-time, please), Devils (absolutely love the Christmas colors), Capitals (This would be an amazing third, if Leonsis can be convinced to go back to the original jerseys for their home and road), Coyotes, Canadiens
Tier 2: Blues (as long as they only wear them once or twice), Blackhawks, Penguins, Kings (I liked the mockups with a yellow logo better, but still quite good), Lightning, Maple Leafs, Sabres, Rangers (docking them a tier for missing the point; would have been tier 1 if red)
Tier 3: Flyers (Tier 1 Phantoms jersey, though), Blue Jackets, Oilers, Panthers (I don't think I've ever liked a jersey of theirs), Senators, Sharks (fine, but they totally should have reversed their original jerseys), Ducks (like the Blues, please only wear this once or twice, but it'll be fun in limited doses; just wish Wild Wing's jersey was a different color)
Tier 4: Bruins, Canucks (the gradient can die now, thanks), Flames (you managed to both miss the point and throw back to your worst idea ever. How?), Golden Knights, Islanders (is this in any way different from what they wore back then?), Jets (just no), Predators, Red Wings (the silver stripes are so much worse than I expected), Stars (same for the silver name)
Stop that: Avalanche, Hurricanes
Can't afford any of them, but if I was going to buy one, it'd be the Wild jersey. I think they're the big winners here.