Post-Game Talk: New York Rangers at New Jersey Devils - December 21

  • Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.
Status
Not open for further replies.
AV is a terrible coach, but he's not responsible for assembling the dumbest group of players in the league. That's on our old GM, our new GM and his team.

Let's look past the fact that this team is never prepared for games, as professional athletes. What the actual f*** are McDonagh and Shattenkirk doing in the first and second goals? These types of brain farts with this team happen at a consistency far above the rest of the league. Your team isn't going to win squat when your captain, who's supposed to lead by example (no, that doesn't mean he has to be most the skilled or the best), makes idiotic decisions on a regular basis. Like a virus, that shit spreads.

Also, the ex Ranger thing is pathetic, and happens far to often to simply dismiss it as bad luck. It's truly remarkable how often it happens, and would be pretty easy to analytically compare with the rest of the league. I'd be willing to bet, like our dumbass mistakes, that is well above league average.
 
AV is such a clown.

we played awful and debs were ready to go. not the shootout lineup i would have chosen but AV gonna AV.

henrik earning his paycheck. loving his game. john moore scores. yeesh. and we get a point when we should have lost by 3 easy. ill take the point and move forward.

we are a very good team that plays dumb. the AV effect.
 
Im a big Shattenkirk fan, but his head has been lodged up his ass for like 7-8 games now. Don’t need numbers to see that.
 
we are a very good team that plays dumb. the AV effect.

We're absolutely a good team that plays dumb, couldn't agree more, but how is that the AV effect?

Playing Vesey in the shootout is his fault, failing to have the team ready at game time is certainly partially on him.

But is it fair to blame AV for McDonagh and Shattenkirk being idiots? I don't see how we can blame AV for McDonagh's lackadaisical failure to clear the zone on goal one. I use that as just one example.
 
Tell that to a good % of people here who thought and still believe Shattenkirk is top pair D. Everytime I would bring up his deficiencies, they would flip out and tell me to **** off. Watch the Blues games. This is Shattenkirk. Far too many people are obsessed with hockey analytics. Shot suppression. Corsi. Shattenkirk is a not a good defender. He makes dumb decisions. Power play specialist. Not a top pair D. Good player. Not a top pair D or an elite D. Not even close. He was supposed to be the #1 D partner for Trucker. How long did that last?
To be fair, AV never gave it a legitimate shot. He broke them up in game 2 of the season at a time when everyone was still playing poorly and Shattenkirk was clearly not adjusted to the system yet.
 
AV simply feels more comfortable having a left-handed defenseman playing the right side. AV gonna AV.
 
AV simply feels more comfortable having a left-handed defenseman playing the right side. AV gonna AV.

How many RHD do we have? Some players are more comfortable playing the right side even though they are left-handed, like Smith.

The real issue is that we play man-defense with personnel more used to playing zone.
 
How many RHD do we have? Some players are more comfortable playing the right side even though they are left-handed, like Smith.

The real issue is that we play man-defense with personnel more used to playing zone.

I was simply following up on the post about not giving Shattenkirk a shot with McDonagh. Each game there is a handful of situations where a natural lefty has more trouble clearing the puck. Last night there was an instance where Holden, if he were a righty, could've swept the puck up the right side boards for a clear. But he had to hold the puck in the corner.

Not disagreeing with you about man-to-man D. We suck at it.
 
This X 1,000. I missed the first period, but from what I saw of the game, the Devils looked like they were playing a 4 point game against a hated division rival and the Rangers looked like they were playing Arizona.

No one who knows how bad the Devils are as a possession team and saw us cream them in possession last time we played them can actually believe it was a skill problem. It was an effort problem, plain and simple. The team takes on the demeanor of the coach.
 
It's funny because people used to complain that he always needed to have LH-RH pairs. Which is actually much more beneficial.

I actually said it in jest. Of course a natural RH-LH pair would make much more sense tactically.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Off Sides
Why not?

The shot will be better.
The idea is that it's more difficult for the defenseman to work their stick along the boards if they're on their offside.

Yes, it's easier to shoot, but their stick is opposite the boards, which makes it easier for opposition to chip the puck up along the boards, or even just skate through there.
 
AV is a terrible coach, but he's not responsible for assembling the dumbest group of players in the league. That's on our old GM, our new GM and his team.

Let's look past the fact that this team is never prepared for games, as professional athletes. What the actual **** are McDonagh and Shattenkirk doing in the first and second goals? These types of brain farts with this team happen at a consistency far above the rest of the league. Your team isn't going to win squat when your captain, who's supposed to lead by example (no, that doesn't mean he has to be most the skilled or the best), makes idiotic decisions on a regular basis. Like a virus, that **** spreads.

Also, the ex Ranger thing is pathetic, and happens far to often to simply dismiss it as bad luck. It's truly remarkable how often it happens, and would be pretty easy to analytically compare with the rest of the league. I'd be willing to bet, like our dumbass mistakes, that is well above league average.

I mean, the McDonagh trade even for all of his warts was still a great trade and the Shattenkirk deal was a steal that most GMs would take and run. So not sure how those two guys making mistakes somehow reflects poorly on the GMs.
 
AV is a terrible coach, but he's not responsible for assembling the dumbest group of players in the league. That's on our old GM, our new GM and his team.

Let's look past the fact that this team is never prepared for games, as professional athletes. What the actual **** are McDonagh and Shattenkirk doing in the first and second goals? These types of brain farts with this team happen at a consistency far above the rest of the league. Your team isn't going to win squat when your captain, who's supposed to lead by example (no, that doesn't mean he has to be most the skilled or the best), makes idiotic decisions on a regular basis. Like a virus, that **** spreads.

Also, the ex Ranger thing is pathetic, and happens far to often to simply dismiss it as bad luck. It's truly remarkable how often it happens, and would be pretty easy to analytically compare with the rest of the league. I'd be willing to bet, like our dumbass mistakes, that is well above league average.

I feel like you gave me a project that I will spend this whole holiday working on. Although it's probably too big of an undertaking to go through all of the scorers of every game for a few seasons. But I'll try. (My guess is I'll give up before I'm done, haha).
 
Generally speaking, what causes mistakes on the backend? Pressure. Not having an out. They make their share of unforced errors, surely, especially Shattenkirk, when they get too fancy. But forwards flying the zone and leaving you no relief valves results in bad choices that look like lazy plays or brainfarts. When was the last time this team consistently went up the ice as a unit?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad