Nathan MacKinnon, on par with the best in business?

[Murzu]

As of right now. I would take Mackinnon over McDavid if I was starting a team and I could only have one of them.

Even with the numbers presented in the opening post, it's a shame people laugh at you. As if different opinions aren't allowed to exist.

 

[TruePowerSlave]

What is even the argument for MacKinnon over McDavid?

One has achieved much more in the league. Even last season McDavid posted a playoff run MacKinnon will never match.

 

[PaulD]

What is even the argument for MacKinnon over McDavid?

One has achieved much more in the league. Even last season McDavid posted a playoff run MacKinnon will never match.

and yet still Looked very average in game 7 with the Cup on the line. He us human after all.
I like Mackinnon over McDavid this season. By a nose.

 

[Frank Drebin]

What is even the argument for MacKinnon over McDavid?

One has achieved much more in the league. Even last season McDavid posted a playoff run MacKinnon will never match.

"I don't like McDavid or the Oilers"

 

[Frank Drebin]

and yet still Looked very average in game 7 with the Cup on the line. He us human after all.
I like Mackinnon over McDavid this season. By a nose.

Mackinnon is a great player.
Hasn't done much without the once in a lifetime roster around him that he had in 2022 where he finished 4th in team scoring in the SCF, and third on his team in overall scoring.

 

[PaulD]

Mackinnon is a great player.
Hasn't done much without the once in a lifetime roster around him that he had in 2022 where he finished 4th in team scoring in the SCF, and third on his team in overall scoring.

I heard he won a Hart and Art Ross last season.

 

[Frank Drebin]

I heard he won a Hart and Art Ross last season.

First time?

 

[daver]

I heard he won a Hart and Art Ross last season.

You heard wrong.