Nashville Predators Talk - 2024/2025 Season

originalpredfan

Registered User
Oct 27, 2013
475
401
I've said before that I questioned if Bruno's system might be the problem and that he should change his system or he himself needs to be changed. Well I no longer question, I am now convinced. If he is too stubborn to adapt his system to the strengths of his players then I see no reason to keep him on board. I still believe these guys are either not truly buying in, or the system is too difficult to operate with their collective skill set. Once again "Dazed and Confused" is the operative word.
 

predfan24

Registered User
Jul 12, 2006
5,117
982
This team needs some youthful legs and enthusiasm to balance out the old legs and laid back wisdom. The best players on the team are at least 30 with many closer to 35 than 30.

Forsberg: 30
Stamkos: 34..35 in a few months
Marchy: 33....34 next month
Nyquist: 35
ROR: 33.....34 in a few months (speed was never his game to begin with)
Josi: 34
Skjei: 30


Vet players who have been useful at times in their careers as Preds but ultimately are mediocre: Smith, Janko, McCarron, Schenn. Why does Brunette have so much loyalty to these guys?

Last night Brunette's answer via ice time strategy when struggling is to cut the young players ice time. The three lowest ice times, respectively, were Evangelista, L'Heureux, Pars.

Maybe I can sort of understand that the ultimate success of the team will depend on our veteran players so double, triple, quadruple down on the until something works but this is brutal.
 

wmupreds

Registered User
Dec 15, 2022
1,198
1,644
This team needs some youthful legs and enthusiasm to balance out the old legs and laid back wisdom. The best players on the team are at least 30 with many closer to 35 than 30.

Forsberg: 30
Stamkos: 34..35 in a few months
Marchy: 33....34 next month
Nyquist: 35
ROR: 33.....34 in a few months (speed was never his game to begin with)
Josi: 34
Skjei: 30


Vet players who have been useful at times in their careers as Preds but ultimately are mediocre: Smith, Janko, McCarron, Schenn. Why does Brunette have so much loyalty to these guys?

Last night Brunette's answer via ice time strategy when struggling is to cut the young players ice time. The three lowest ice times, respectively, were Evangelista, L'Heureux, Pars.

Maybe I can sort of understand that the ultimate success of the team will depend on our veteran players so double, triple, quadruple down on the until something works but this is brutal.
There's no question that the team will only be successful if the vets you mention get it going. But that's no justification (as you say) to cut those three guys' ice times the way he did last night. None of them were playing particularly poorly. Vange has been off, for sure, though certainly no worse than most of the vets. The other two I thought played quite well. I can't come up with a coherent explanation for how ice time is currently being distributed.
 

Kat Predator

Registered User
Nov 28, 2019
4,226
4,345
Good news: we're tied with Montreal, Buffalo, and Philly for the 2nd slot in the ping-pong ball derby.

Bad news: if you happen to be a coach working for the Preds.
 

Top 6 Spaling

Registered User
Jun 23, 2010
12,440
380
Smashville
silly question. might be my MS acting up. TBL come to you offering a 2nd for Stamkos at 50%. Would you take it?
Unless we're actually going to blow it up in a big way (like, get people to waive their NMCs and trade Forsberg+ROR+Josi type of blow it up), I don't want to get out of Joey and Duchene's dead money just to be saddled with Stamkos's. Pass, but it's interesting to think about
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bringer of Jollity

Top 6 Spaling

Registered User
Jun 23, 2010
12,440
380
Smashville
Forsberg: 30 - NMC, signed til he's 36
Stamkos: 34 - NMC, signed til he's 38
Marchy: 33 - NMC, signed til he's 38
Nyquist: 35 - UFA after this year
ROR: 33 - signed til he's 35
Josi: 34 - NMC, signed til he's 38
Skjei: 30 - NMC, signed til he's 37
Saros; 29 - NMC starting next year, signed til he's 38

Added contract expiry age to your comment above - unless a ton of people want to waive NMCs, which I can't imagine they would given how recently we signed them, we're stuck. Our top guys are old, signed forever, have full control over trades, and are underperforming. We can't make major changes without their buy-in. The only change we can really make is Bruno.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kat Predator

BigFatCat999

First Fubu and now Pred303. !@#$! you cancer
Apr 23, 2007
19,205
3,261
Campbell, NY
Unless we're actually going to blow it up in a big way (like, get people to waive their NMCs and trade Forsberg+ROR+Josi type of blow it up), I don't want to get out of Joey and Duchene's dead money just to be saddled with Stamkos's. Pass, but it's interesting to think about

Just a thought, but I’m going too thick more about it at game 20
 

ShagDaddy

Registered User
Nov 24, 2021
2,512
3,311
The Boro
Trotz isn’t going to be able to move all those older players. Theres really only one person he can move to attempt to drastically change how the team performs. I’m not advocating for this but that’s the only single move he could make.
 

Scoresberg

Perpetual Mediocrity
May 28, 2015
10,467
5,439
Earth
Trotz isn’t going to be able to move all those older players. Theres really only one person he can move to attempt to drastically change how the team performs. I’m not advocating for this but that’s the only single move he could make.
Exactly. There's really no other option to try to change the course.
 

nullednumbed

Registered User
Jun 27, 2022
134
140
Added contract expiry age to your comment above - unless a ton of people want to waive NMCs, which I can't imagine they would given how recently we signed them, we're stuck. Our top guys are old, signed forever, have full control over trades, and are underperforming. We can't make major changes without their buy-in. The only change we can really make is Bruno.
So many old dudes with NMCs - no rebuild is plausible with all of those anchors.
 

Scoresberg

Perpetual Mediocrity
May 28, 2015
10,467
5,439
Earth
Maybe he should tell his coach to give the current younger players a legitimate chance to play....

Some interesting quotes on that one:

"(Filip) Forsberg, (Roman) Josi, (Ryan) O'Reilly, (Brady) Skjei, and of course Stamkos and Marchessault, they are here," Trotz said. "They aren't going anywhere. And (Juuse) Saros. But everybody else, I might pull out and put in a young kid."

"If we don't find that (second line center) then maybe we start the process of letting some of those kids come up and play with Stamkos at center," Trotz said. "Maybe Reid Schaefer or (Zachary) L'Heureux or (Joakim) Kemell has to go in that wing spot."
 

Armourboy

Hey! You suck!
Jan 20, 2014
20,547
12,210
Shelbyville, TN
Some interesting quotes on that one:

"(Filip) Forsberg, (Roman) Josi, (Ryan) O'Reilly, (Brady) Skjei, and of course Stamkos and Marchessault, they are here," Trotz said. "They aren't going anywhere. And (Juuse) Saros. But everybody else, I might pull out and put in a young kid."

"If we don't find that (second line center) then maybe we start the process of letting some of those kids come up and play with Stamkos at center," Trotz said. "Maybe Reid Schaefer or (Zachary) L'Heureux or (Joakim) Kemell has to go in that wing spot."
I'll believe it when I see it.
 

Flgatorguy87

Registered User
Jul 7, 2011
6,014
3,989
East Nasty
Evangelista seems to have regressed this year. He's taken his playmaking capability and turned it into over thinking and playing slower than he is. I'm not sure where the fault lies, but it's frustrating to watch.
 
  • Like
Reactions: darth5

Predsanddead24

Registered User
Mar 7, 2019
5,913
6,577
Reading between the lines I'm guessing this means Novak and Luke are in increasing danger now. Ol' 20 minutes a night Steve totally in the clear though.
Yeah this quote honestly makes me feel worse about where we stand. Seems like Trotz is unwilling to put any blame on Stamkos for playing poorly and instead will just push the blame to the guys playing with him which is just insane. Quite frankly everyone on the team needs to be better but it's insane to blame the guys that aren't getting forcefed ice time.
 

Porter Stoutheart

Seen Stamkos?
Jun 14, 2017
15,999
12,417
"(Filip) Forsberg, (Roman) Josi, (Ryan) O'Reilly, (Brady) Skjei, and of course Stamkos and Marchessault, they are here," Trotz said. "They aren't going anywhere. And (Juuse) Saros. But everybody else, I might pull out and put in a young kid."

I mean, if he pulls out any of Sissons, Smith, McCarron, Jankowski and puts in a young kid, great. Or if it's on D, sure, pull out Lauzon and Carrier and Schenn... you didn't name them. I'll believe it when I see it. But that's the stuff we actually need to do.
 

MrJoshua

Registered User
Mar 24, 2010
1,568
349
Decatur, AL
Yeah that’s all easier said than done unless he’s willing to just straight up waive guys, which would be terrible asset management. Otherwise it takes time to trade people, and without roster space you can’t actually call anyone up.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad