Toggle sidebar

Proposal: Montreal offer for Rick Nash

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
Ok... this is like the 3rd Nash proposal on the first page. Can a mod just merge them all? I get it, nyr want to see what value they can get for nash; other fans say not as much as NY wants, NY crap on the proposal, other teams fans crap on nash- rinse repeat. Just merge it all into one all encompassing bash thread. For giggles though, I'd give a b prospect and a 1st for him.
 
Doriva said:
Most likely one of the more realistic offers on this board, inb4 the "he's a worthless cap dump" brigade show up.
Click to expand...

Just a downright terrible offer for the Habs .
If the Rangers are willing to eat 50% of his contract than come back and we will talk otherwise keep your cap dump.
 
and again, Nash has a no trade clause to all Canadian teams, so no matter what the proposal, no matter how it would be for either team involved, it just ain't gonna happen.
 
Really don't think you'll see Nash returning more than Kessel... From Montreal I'd do Emelin + Ghetto + conditional 2nd (based on either Nash or team's performance)
 
NA Scouting said:
With the Rangers adding Pirri and Vesey it seems they have a surplus of forwards, plus they have been rumoured for a while to be shopping Nash around. Since they have a pretty complete line-up even without Nash, I will assume that the Rangers would be incline to accept a picks/prospects type of deal, and save some cap space for in-season dealings.

Now as a Habs fan I would be willing to pay a fairly high price for Nash, even given his 7.8M cap hit. For this to happen though, Montreal would likely need to ditch Desharnais and Emelin (yes, both). There might be suitors around the league, but it may not be realistic to think that Bergevin could pull it off. Unless the NYR take on one of them in the Nash deal, which could make sense. So yes in instance this deal is a pretty long shot, but I still wanna put it out there.

My offer:

-MTL 1st round pick 2017 (not lottery protected)
-Your choice of Martin Reway or Arturri Lehkonen
-Your choice of Sven Andrighetto or Daniel Carr
-Possibly one of Desharnais/Emelin

Comments?
Click to expand...

That's not bad value wise at all.

I'll take the 1st, and Reway.

I'll take a contract, or two no problem. One like Desharnais, another like Redmond/Pateryn.

Juulsen.

I'll throw in Fast, and a good pro prospect. Tambo, Fogarty (think Paul Gaustad). With Nash.
 
Mikos87 said:
That's not bad value wise at all.

I'll take the 1st, and Reway.

I'll take a contract, or two no problem. One like Desharnais, another like Redmond/Pateryn.

Juulsen.

I'll throw in Fast, and a good pro prospect. Tambo, Fogarty (think Paul Gaustad). With Nash.
Click to expand...

not happening. just keep nash
 
outch

NA Scouting said:
With the Rangers adding Pirri and Vesey it seems they have a surplus of forwards, plus they have been rumoured for a while to be shopping Nash around. Since they have a pretty complete line-up even without Nash, I will assume that the Rangers would be incline to accept a picks/prospects type of deal, and save some cap space for in-season dealings.

Now as a Habs fan I would be willing to pay a fairly high price for Nash, even given his 7.8M cap hit. For this to happen though, Montreal would likely need to ditch Desharnais and Emelin (yes, both). There might be suitors around the league, but it may not be realistic to think that Bergevin could pull it off. Unless the NYR take on one of them in the Nash deal, which could make sense. So yes in instance this deal is a pretty long shot, but I still wanna put it out there.

My offer:

-MTL 1st round pick 2017 (not lottery protected)
-Your choice of Martin Reway or Arturri Lehkonen
-Your choice of Sven Andrighetto or Daniel Carr
-Possibly one of Desharnais/Emelin

Comments?
Click to expand...

Terrible deal for the habs man i'm i glad you have nothing to do with decision making for my habs.
 
This proposal was from a Habs fan, BTW. Rangers fans know Nash has his all Canadian team no trade clause.
 
The heck is this offer?

Nash's is an albatross contract and he's on the decline. Canadiens need a top 6 LW but they aren't so desperate as to overpay massively for an albatross like Nash when Lehkonen has a real chance of being a better player in a year or two.
 
Are people intentionally ignoring the fact that Nash has no Canadian teams on his list of acceptable teams?

Enough with the Nash to (insert Canadian team here) threads.
 
NA Scouting said:
With the Rangers adding Pirri and Vesey it seems they have a surplus of forwards, plus they have been rumoured for a while to be shopping Nash around. Since they have a pretty complete line-up even without Nash, I will assume that the Rangers would be incline to accept a picks/prospects type of deal, and save some cap space for in-season dealings.

Now as a Habs fan I would be willing to pay a fairly high price for Nash, even given his 7.8M cap hit. For this to happen though, Montreal would likely need to ditch Desharnais and Emelin (yes, both). There might be suitors around the league, but it may not be realistic to think that Bergevin could pull it off. Unless the NYR take on one of them in the Nash deal, which could make sense. So yes in instance this deal is a pretty long shot, but I still wanna put it out there.

My offer:

-MTL 1st round pick 2017 (not lottery protected)
-Your choice of Martin Reway or Arturri Lehkonen
-Your choice of Sven Andrighetto or Daniel Carr
-Possibly one of Desharnais/Emelin

Comments?
Click to expand...

That's not a "fairly high price"
That's a dented, scuffed, scratched bargin-basement price for Nash. :laugh:
 
NA Scouting said:
With the Rangers adding Pirri and Vesey it seems they have a surplus of forwards, plus they have been rumoured for a while to be shopping Nash around. Since they have a pretty complete line-up even without Nash, I will assume that the Rangers would be incline to accept a picks/prospects type of deal, and save some cap space for in-season dealings.

Now as a Habs fan I would be willing to pay a fairly high price for Nash, even given his 7.8M cap hit. For this to happen though, Montreal would likely need to ditch Desharnais and Emelin (yes, both). There might be suitors around the league, but it may not be realistic to think that Bergevin could pull it off. Unless the NYR take on one of them in the Nash deal, which could make sense. So yes in instance this deal is a pretty long shot, but I still wanna put it out there.

My offer:

-MTL 1st round pick 2017 (not lottery protected)
-Your choice of Martin Reway or Arturri Lehkonen
-Your choice of Sven Andrighetto or Daniel Carr
-Possibly one of Desharnais/Emelin

Comments?
Click to expand...

nope, not giving up carr, lehkonen, a 1st and emelin for nash
 
Didn't Nash already provide a list that included NO (zero!, 0) Canadian teams on it?


people creating these threads, and mods allowing it is exactly why this site is a train wreck.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom