Proposal: Montreal/Minnesota

[Rask Decisions]

...... ok bro

Would you give up Galchenyuk for Christian Folin, Jason Pominville with some retained, Chris Stewart and a 3rd?

Didn't think so...

 

[rhinoshawarma]

bad on both sides, and needs are not met

 

[Kobe Armstrong]

Would you give up Galchenyuk for Christian Folin, Jason Pominville with some retained, Chris Stewart and a 3rd?

Didn't think so...

That's not even close to comparable to the OP though...

My point is that Galchenyuk and Nino aren't in the same realm of value.

 

[redwings25]

nino and haula where the wild best 2 players after yeo got fired and it wasnt even close. they will not be traded no matter how bad canadian teams seem to want them.

 

[Goose312]

Wow OP is bad. I feel like this a deal where the OP thought they were sneaky trying to get Nino hoping the Wild wouldn't realize he's more valuable than his production would suggest.

That's not even close to comparable to the OP though...

My point is that Galchenyuk and Nino aren't in the same realm of value.

His point is more than the Wild aren't interested in spare parts for a very good young forward. If you want value you give value. Galchenyuk is the only thing on your roster of value to the Wild.

 

[Digitalbooya]

That's not even close to comparable to the OP though...

My point is that Galchenyuk and Nino aren't in the same realm of value.

That's fine and all but Nino isn't being moved unless the names Galchenyuk, Gallagher, Pacioretty, Weber or Price are involved. Those are the pieces we will package Nino+ for. Hilarious proposal with DD included...

 

[gwh]

That's not even close to comparable to the OP though...

My point is that Galchenyuk and Nino aren't in the same realm of value.

Yes, Galchenyuk sure looks so much better.

http://puckalytics.com/#/skaters?TO...1669,1354&showFilters=true&Team=&Player_Name=

10% offensive bump against 20% less goals against per 60. Apples and oranges, if you ask me.

 

[the paisanos guy]

Yes, Galchenyuk sure looks so much better.

http://puckalytics.com/#/skaters?TO...1669,1354&showFilters=true&Team=&Player_Name=

10% offensive bump against 20% less goals against per 60. Apples and oranges, if you ask me.

Chuck is a year and a half younger and outscored Nino by a wide margin. Be real

 

[rynryn]

Chuck is a year and a half younger and outscored Nino by a wide margin. Be real

plus he's from WI and...our owner is from WI and seems pretty provincial. So you could squeeze more from us I think.

 

[Digitalbooya]

Chuck is a year and a half younger and outscored Nino by a wide margin. Be real

5v5 was actually pretty close. Nino didn't have the luxury of playing on the top power play.

 

[CristianoRonaldo]

5v5 was actually pretty close. Nino didn't have the luxury of playing on the top power play.

Galchenyuk played 2:33 pp minutes per night.

Nino Played 2:00 pp minutes per night.

 

[Digitalbooya]

Galchenyuk played 2:33 pp minutes per night.

Nino Played 2:00 pp minutes per night.

Nino played second unit... As in spent the majority of the 30-45 seconds per pp getting the puck and moving it into the zone.

 

[missthenet]

The exact opposite of what the wild need to do. If they even need to make a move as of now it would be for a forward. Specifically a center. They wouldn't want to take on another defenseman with the cluster they have around the 6th spot. They have 2 or 3 ready to play in the NHL defenseman already waiting. So no point in moving forward with this post. Sorry buddy.

But he is offering you David Desharnais in the deal, how can you refuse?

 

[CristianoRonaldo]

Nino played second unit... As in spent the majority of the 30-45 seconds per pp getting the puck and moving it into the zone.

Galchenyuk too played on the second unit...

 

[Digitalbooya]

Galchenyuk too played on the second unit...

Odd he's in the top 5 for pp toi for Montreal. Interesting and noted.

Even as far as second units go Galchenyuk still got 50 more minutes than Nino, whom was #8 on Minnesota's pp toi list.

 

[Kobe Armstrong]

I'd challenge you to start a Niederreter vs Galchenyuk poll...

Would be closed within 2 hours

 

[Digitalbooya]

I'd challenge you to start a Niederreter vs Galchenyuk poll...

Would be closed within 2 hours

It's not hard to figure out 56 is a bigger number than 43 and that center is a more important position than wing. I'm not saying Nino has equal or more value than Galchenyuk but the thought of him being way far behind when looking at the underlying numbers is, well, off IMO. Nino had 34 5v5 points. Galchenyuk had 36 5v5 points. Majority of the game is spent 5v5. Galchenyuk had 11 more power play points than Nino.

 

[gwh]

Chuck is a year and a half younger and outscored Nino by a wide margin. Be real

On powerplay. Which was a tirefire under Yeo.

Look at the stat lines and repeat "on different planet"... Starts to sound real funny after couple rounds.

 

[Halla]

the wild already have 5 good dmen, one of which is gonna get snagged by vegas. doesnt make a lick of sense to make a move for a guy that would be their #6dman

 

[Benstheman]

Considering age and production, Galchenyuk is 2 big steps ahead of Nino.

I would still take nino in my team any day of the week.

As for the OP, take that DD thing of of the equation and the value is pretty good. People reaaly underestimate beaulieu's value on HF.

That being said, Minn doesn't need Beaulieu.

 

[tony d]

Doubt either team does this.

 

[Benstheman]

Would you give up Galchenyuk for Christian Folin, Jason Pominville with some retained, Chris Stewart and a 3rd?

Didn't think so...

While i can agree on Pminville and DD, your other comparaisons are way off man.

 

[Digitalbooya]

People reaaly underestimate beaulieu's value on HF.

That being said, Minn doesn't need Beaulieu.

Nice...

 

[thestonedkoala]

One thing that Nino does that Galy doesn't provide is the agitator and physical role. Minnesota is a soft team without Nino.

 

[The Great Weal]

One thing that Nino does that Galy doesn't provide is the agitator and physical role. Minnesota is a soft team without Nino.

One thing that Chucky does that Nino hasent provided is scoring 30 goals