Proposal: Montreal and Winnipeg

[Nico Cauzuki]

If Habs dont finish with the 1st overall pick would both teams do this trade

To MTL :

Pierre Luc Dubois


To WPG :

2022 Calgary 1st Round Pick
Kaiden Guhle
Ryan Poehling


Habs draft Nemec with our pick

Click to read more...

 

[Tasteless Beaver]

PLD not for sale. I see him getting 7 years this summer.

 

[tgo0]

Jets would decline without a counter.

 

[Garbageyuk]

So three 1sts for a 2nd liner? Yeah no thanks.

 

[Habby4Life]

So three 1sts for a 2nd liner? Yeah no thanks.

Well, RP might be a first round draft pick but he is hardly anything special. It is essentially Guhle and the Flames 1st for PLD which is not enough.

 

[pth2]

I can see why Winnipeg doesn't do this, but I can also see that Guhle and a 1st are a decent offer. Just not enough. We'd have to add a useful roster player and even then, it becomes a timing issue: Winnipeg isn't rebuilding from scratch.

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

So three 1sts for a 2nd liner? Yeah no thanks.

Poehling is no 1st rounder now, You'd be lucky to get a 3rd or 4th round pick for him. And yeah players like PLD could return 3 1st rounders rather easily.

 

[Snowman]

Other than the 1st, there isn't anything that fills a need or want for the Jets. Winnipeg turns it down without question.

 

[Mrfenn92]

Jets say no easily

 

[OG Eberle]

So three 1sts for a 2nd liner? Yeah no thanks.

Would've saved you some time/characters just to say "I haven't watched PLD play this year"

 

[CanadienShark]

Jets decline.

 

[HabsWhiteKnightLOL]

awful for Jets and awful for habs because we need Guhle

 

[doomscroll]

So three 1sts for a 2nd liner? Yeah no thanks.

Just because a player was taken in the first round doesn’t mean they have the value of a first-round pick. Regardless, Winnipeg says no emphatically.

 

[Adam da bomb]

If Habs dont finish with the 1st overall pick would both teams do this trade

To MTL :

Pierre Luc Dubois


To WPG :

2022 Calgary 1st Round Pick
Kaiden Guhle
Ryan Poehling


Habs draft Nemec with our pick

Nope. As soon as you mention pld it’s ridiculous.

 

[Adam da bomb]

So three 1sts for a 2nd liner? Yeah no thanks.

You’re name describes this post. Garbage yuck. Jets would never do this.

 

[Garbageyuk]

You’re name describes this post. Garbage yuck. Jets would never do this.

Wow clever. Habs don’t entertain this.

 

[Heldig]

If Habs dont finish with the 1st overall pick would both teams do this trade

To MTL :

Pierre Luc Dubois


To WPG :

2022 Calgary 1st Round Pick
Kaiden Guhle
Ryan Poehling


Habs draft Nemec with our pick

Only deal that would make sense is Suzuki +

 

[Boss Man Hughes]

You’re name describes this post. Garbage yuck. Jets would never do this.

Well, RP might be a first round draft pick but he is hardly anything special. It is essentially Guhle and the Flames 1st for PLD which is not enough

Only deal that would make sense is Suzuki +

Absolutely ridiculous. Suzuki is better than Dubois. The plus would be on Winnipeg's side. But Winnipeg has very few good players so they can't afford to move Dubois unless they are getting a lot back.

 

[Cenzo_]

Dubois and Suzuki have very very similar value. Would you trade Suzuki for a late first, a very good D prospect and a potential 3rd line C?

 

[Heldig]

Absolutely ridiculous. Suzuki is better than Dubois. The plus would be on Winnipeg's side. But Winnipeg has very few good players so they can't afford to move Dubois unless they are getting a lot back.

OK, maybe you could make an argument that Suzuki is better. I think you would be wrong since Dubois out paces Suzuki in most categories as per Natural Stat Trick. They are close in value IMO but if Montreal is trying to acquire Dubois the ask is Suzuki, no doubt.

And then your juvenile comment that "Winnipeg has very few good players". Compared to Montreal they are stacked!

While not a good team, the Jets have Connor, Dubois, Ehlers, Scheifele who would all play in your top 6. Morrissey would be your #1 D and Hellebucyk your #1 goalie.

 

[Boss Man Hughes]

OK, maybe you could make an argument that Suzuki is better. I think you would be wrong since Dubois out paces Suzuki in most categories as per Natural Stat Trick. They are close in value IMO but if Montreal is trying to acquire Dubois the ask is Suzuki, no doubt.

And then your juvenile comment that "Winnipeg has very few good players". Compared to Montreal they are stacked!

While not a good team, the Jets have Connor, Dubois, Ehlers, Scheifele who would all play in your top 6. Morrissey would be your #1 D and Hellebucyk your #1 goalie.

So what? I never said Montreal had a good team. They are rebuilding. Winnipeg is solid in net. Of course Canadiens might be too if Price returns. Jets are lacking in depth.
In any event Suzuki and Dubois are close but Suzuki is a leader and I am not convinced Dubois is a guy you win with. And I'd rather add a Wright or Cooley to Habs group of centres (if they get the chance) than Dubois.

 

[Big Empty]

Poehling is no 1st rounder now, You'd be lucky to get a 3rd or 4th round pick for him. And yeah players like PLD could return 3 1st rounders rather easily.

 

[pth2]

Poehling is no 1st rounder now, You'd be lucky to get a 3rd or 4th round pick for him. And yeah players like PLD could return 3 1st rounders rather easily.

I have to admit, as a Habs fan, if we could add PLD for the Flames pick this year, Florida's pick next year, and another pick from a playoff team (or a Habs 2nd which is almost a 1st rounder, and with a 3d could probably be traded for a 1st), I'd do it in a second. And that would be 3 1sts.
PLD, Suzuki, Dvorak and Evans would be a great C core to build around.

 

[Adam da bomb]

So what? I never said Montreal had a good team. They are rebuilding. Winnipeg is solid in net. Of course Canadiens might be too if Price returns. Jets are lacking in depth.
In any event Suzuki and Dubois are close but Suzuki is a leader and I am not convinced Dubois is a guy you win with. And I'd rather add a Wright or Cooley to Habs group of centres (if they get the chance) than Dubois.

Cool it was a mtl fan who made this post not a jet so no deal from both teams.
Cool all the numbers say Pld is a leader but your gut… great way for making any decisions.

 

[Adam da bomb]

Wow clever. Habs don’t entertain this.

You don’t gotta be clever when the other person makes it so obvious and easy. Jets don’t even answer phone.