Player Discussion Mitch Marner, Yet Again

[SoupNazi]

Continued from Player Discussion - Mitch Marner, Again

NO PERSONAL ATTACKS, OR YOU'LL FEEL MY WRATH. AND I'M PARTICULARLY VENGEFUL.

Click to read more...

 

[Ports]

Can the Marner money be better deployed in other areas is an important question because to me it’s about can this core group win a cup together and I don’t think they can. Too similar, too soft and don’t have it in them to battle as hard as their opponents will. They’re not going to suddenly change to become gritty superstars like Crosby, Toews or Kucherov and how can they find that player / leader with these guys running the show ?

As bad as the optics might be, if they flame out in the playoffs again, major roster changes must happen. Let Marner walk, sign Tavares as a 3C to $4M x 4 or let him walk, buyout or trade Domi, take the $22M in addition cap space and bring in players that know how to win when it counts like Bennett, Braydon Schenn, Marchand … Target Chychrun, Eckblad as UFA’s or Rasmus Andersson who is one year away.

If McDavid doesn’t re-sign over the summer in Edmonton, they need to plan to have cap space available for him if he gets to UFA in July 2026 or perhaps trade for him prior to that because Edmonton won’t want to see him walk away for nothing.

Moving off their core group and Thinking outside the box is something the Shanahan Leafs have never been prepared to do. Let’s hope he’s no longer around to prevent it from happening.

 

[thewave]

My opinion is that Mitch Marner is not good for us because he is slow and weak. He does get points in the regular season, but consistently fades in important playoff games. He has been a key member to a core that has won a single playoff series over the past 8 years.

I feel it would be wise to trade him for Crosby if we can get Sid to sign an extra year and hope for McDavid.

Discuss.

Lastly. I think I am right because the people that disagree have only 8 years of being wrong.

Thank you

 

[ULF_55]

From everything we've read he'll re-sign this summer, and will be highest paid player on the team.

Who knows maybe it will be as the Conn Smythe winner?

 

[keonsbitterness]

My opinion is that Mitch Marner is not good for us because he is slow and weak. He does get points in the regular season, but consistently fades in important playoff games. He has been a key member to a core that has won a single playoff series over the past 8 years.

I feel it would be wise to trade him for Crosby if we can get Sid to sign an extra year and hope for McDavid.

Discuss.

Lastly. I think I am right because the people that disagree have only 8 years of being wrong.

Thank you

Trading a player who won't waive for a player who won't waive and whose team doesn't want to trade is a pointless discussion.

 

[thewave]

Trading a player who won't waive for a player who won't waive and whose team doesn't want to trade is a pointless discussion.

We don't know that. Marner loves Dubas. Crosby loves a challenge and winning.

Unless they say that how do we know. Maybe Crosby would be up for the challenge. Record book stuff, legend maker

 

[ToneDog]

My opinion is that Mitch Marner is not good for us because he is slow and weak. He does get points in the regular season, but consistently fades in important playoff games. He has been a key member to a core that has won a single playoff series over the past 8 years.

I feel it would be wise to trade him for Crosby if we can get Sid to sign an extra year and hope for McDavid.

Discuss.

Lastly. I think I am right because the people that disagree have only 8 years of being wrong.

Thank you

The game against the Americans will show us if he can play against a physical team. If both teams show up, I expect Marner to stay away from any type of contact.

Assuming we beat Finland and USA or Finland beat Sweden, I am not sure we should go all out Saturday night. Beating the USA twice in their barn is no easy feat IMO. We need to win the second game.

 

[Gary Nylund]

From everything we've read he'll re-sign this summer, and will be highest paid player on the team.

Who knows maybe it will be as the Conn Smythe winner?

If Marner wins the Conn Smythe, I will blow kisses at him at the victory parade as I'm taking victory laps around him on my flying pig.

 

[ToneDog]

Can the Marner money be better deployed in other areas is an important question because to me it’s about can this core group win a cup together and I don’t think they can. Too similar, too soft and don’t have it in them to battle as hard as their opponents will. They’re not going to suddenly change to become gritty superstars like Crosby, Toews or Kucherov and how can they find that player / leader with these guys running the show ?

As bad as the optics might be, if they flame out in the playoffs again, major roster changes must happen. Let Marner walk, sign Tavares as a 3C to $4M x 4 or let him walk, buyout or trade Domi, take the $22M in addition cap space and bring in players that know how to win when it counts like Bennett, Braydon Schenn, Marchand … Target Chychrun, Eckblad as UFA’s or Rasmus Andersson who is one year away.

If McDavid doesn’t re-sign over the summer in Edmonton, they need to plan to have cap space available for him if he gets to UFA in July 2026 or perhaps trade for him prior to that because Edmonton won’t want to see him walk away for nothing.

Moving off their core group and Thinking outside the box is something the Shanahan Leafs have never been prepared to do. Let’s hope he’s no longer around to prevent it from happening.

No way they bring Shanahan back if they flame out in the playoffs again. I would go shopping on July 1 and only sign Tavares if I cannot find better bang for the buck. We need to add speed and grit.

If we only had a second line that brings what the Eichel, Brady and Matthew line brought last night. That was something to watch. Will be interesting to see if Canada can contain them.

 

[Doublerum1975]

My opinion is that Mitch Marner is not good for us because he is slow and weak. He does get points in the regular season, but consistently fades in important playoff games. He has been a key member to a core that has won a single playoff series over the past 8 years.

I feel it would be wise to trade him for Crosby if we can get Sid to sign an extra year and hope for McDavid.

Discuss.

Lastly. I think I am right because the people that disagree have only 8 years of being wrong.

Thank you

That’s nice putting all the team’s failures on one person

 

[Zybalto]

If Marner wins the Conn Smythe, I will blow kisses at him at the victory parade as I'm making victory circles around him on my flying pig.

Gonna hold you to that!

 

[Gary Nylund]

That’s nice putting all the team’s failures on one person

Looks like you didn't understand what you're responding to, try reading the post again.

 

[hullsy47]

From everything we've read he'll re-sign this summer, and will be highest paid player on the team.

Who knows maybe it will be as the Conn Smythe winner?

Nor so sure .ted rogers takes control once he gets to but alot msle
He went after ohtani he ll throw the max at mcdavid
These guys win a few rounds this year or i see a BIG change

 

[BTP]

Looks like Mitch is gonna be a dad, his wife just posted pregnancy pics

 

[Apex Predator]

Looks like Mitch is gonna be a dad, his wife just posted pregnancy pics

So he’s going to have a down year after signing an extension with the leafs. That will be fun next season.

 

[BraveCanadian]

So he’s going to have a down year after signing an extension with the leafs. That will be fun next season.

He’s been quite consistent the past several years so..

 

[Hellcat]

Trading a player who won't waive for a player who won't waive and whose team doesn't want to trade is a pointless discussion.

If these Marner threads have one thing, it people with super creative imaginations.

 

[Hellcat]

He’s been quite consistent the past several years so..

It's a well known bugaboo for pro athletes when the first baby comes, the lifestyle adjustment can affect their game. Could just be a wives tale. Ask Morgan how his season following the birth of his first child this past summer has been going.

 

[The Hanging Jowl]

If Marner wins the Conn Smythe, I will blow kisses at him at the victory parade as I'm taking victory laps around him on my flying pig.

 

[arso40]

View attachment 977390

I’m crying I love that episode

 

[Smif]

My opinion is that Mitch Marner is not good for us because he is slow and weak. He does get points in the regular season, but consistently fades in important playoff games. He has been a key member to a core that has won a single playoff series over the past 8 years.

I feel it would be wise to trade him for Crosby if we can get Sid to sign an extra year and hope for McDavid.

Discuss.

Lastly. I think I am right because the people that disagree have only 8 years of being wrong.

Thank you

It's a dream of yours not worth discussing. Just shut it down in your head, it's not happening.