Speculation: Matthew Knies next contract

  • We sincerely apologize for the extended downtime. Our hosting provider, XenForo Cloud, encountered a major issue with their backup system, which unfortunately resulted in the loss of some critical data from the past year.

    What This Means for You:

    • If you created an account after March 2024, it no longer exists. You will need to sign up again to access the forum.
    • If you registered before March 2024 but changed your email, username, or password in the past year, those changes were lost. You’ll need to update your account details manually once you're logged in.
    • Threads and posts created within the last year have been restored.

    Our team is working with Xenforo Cloud to recover data using backups, sitemaps, and other available resources. We know this is frustrating, and we deeply regret the impact on our community. We are taking steps with Xenforo Cloud to ensure this never happens again. This is work in progress. Thank you for your patience and support as we work through this.

    In the meantime, feel free to join our Discord Server
I'd give Knies a 9 mil offer sheet no problem.

Would be interesting to see Toronto's response. Knies at that number plus Marner at 14? and Tavares at 7? eats up all their cap space, without any improvements to the roster or even filling out the roster.
 
I think that Rossi's contract will be a good indication of what Knies will get. There is no doubt that there will be inflation due to rising cap, but paying more than 7M/yr for Knies strikes me as unwise... maybe if they lock him down for 8x8M?

He strikes me as a middle six power forward who's stats are being inflated because of who he plays with. You want guys like him on your team, but not if you have to overpay for him.
 
That's not bad actually. I could see some teams paying that.
I love Knies and he's pacing 30 goals and 55 points with Matthews and Marner. But take him off that line and he's probably closer to 20-25 goals and 45 points. If some team offered him 9 million I would laugh my ass off. I think he's a dominant power forward and clutch, but he's defintley worth closer to 6-7 million. I'd give 7 years, 7 million per as my max offer if we're getting term. If it's a shorter term deal, it should be closer to 6.5.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Hockey Tonk Man
I love Knies and he's pacing 30 goals and 55 points with Matthews and Marner. But take him off that line and he's probably closer to 20-25 goals and 45 points. If some team offered him 9 million I would laugh my ass off. I think he's a dominant power forward and clutch, but he's defintley worth closer to 6-7 million. I'd give 7 years, 7 million per as my max offer if we're getting term. If it's a shorter term deal, it should be closer to 6.5.

Toronto has $27M for next season, and they need to resign Marner, Knies and Tavares, and sign another 4 forwards (Robertson amongst them). Tough task.
 
The Leafs should offer him something similar to Slaf. They have similar production this year but Slaf signed with a lower max cap but is also younger/more room for growth, yoh could argue those offset. 8 year 7.5 million.
 
Toronto has $27M for next season, and they need to resign Marner, Knies and Tavares, and sign another 4 forwards (Robertson amongst them). Tough task.

Toronto would match any compensation under a 1st for Knies. They were already talking about ~5M long-term before the season started (which is over a 1st).

I doubt teams are lining up to offersheet away an unconditional 1st round pick in the Gavin McKenna draft given he's putting up Crosby numbers in his draft -1 season.

If I'm the Leafs and any team is throwing you an unconditional first in the McKenna draft, you seriously consider not matching. An unconditional first is incredibly valuable, you rarely see it ever traded. Nearly all 1sts are protected to avoid the team winning the lottery - let alone in a draft where the player probably sweeps 1st overall the year before he's even eligible.
 
His obvious comp is Boldy and Knies hasn't done enough to make as much as him at $7. Knies is an obvious bridge deal at $5-5.5x3.

I can also see a world where both parties are happy with $7x8 with rising cap and all.
 
Fla or some Team that is near the top of the standings (holding their 1st rders) will possibly make a huge offer . A 1st rder around 25 is basically a 2nd rder so why not with the Cap going up ?
 
Tuch signed his when the salary cap was much lower. An equal salary by percentage would be 7M in todays cap world.
5.83% was Tuch's cap hit %

5.83% of 95.5 = 5.567,650 x 7

Again, Toronto gets hosed and likely wouldn't get 7 years which is why I said 6x6.
 
Fla or some Team that is near the top of the standings (holding their 1st rders) will possibly make a huge offer . A 1st rder around 25 is basically a 2nd rder so why not with the Cap going up ?
The teams near the top of the standings do not have the cap space to accommodate Knies.
 
The teams near the top of the standings do not have the cap space to accommodate Knies.
I think they would but most of these teams dont meet the qualifcations for what it would take. Anything over 6.8 a year only Buffalo Chicago Montreal Nashville Montreal NYI Philly and Utah can do.

Utah Montreal Detroit are all interesting RFA Offersheet canidates
 
I think they would but most of these teams dont meet the qualifcations for what it would take. Anything over 6.8 a year only Buffalo Chicago Montreal Nashville Montreal NYI Philly and Utah can do.

Utah Montreal Detroit are all interesting RFA Offersheet canidates
This entire discussion is predicated on the Leafs being unable to sign Knies because his ask will be too high. In no universe is Knies worth 9, and a team would be dumb to offer sheet him to that. I understand the cap is going up but Knies is not a play driver and his numbers are certainly inflated by his line mates. He’s a guy you’d love to have on your team but he’s not someone you make one of the highest paid on your team.
 
This entire discussion is predicated on the Leafs being unable to sign Knies because his ask will be too high. In no universe is Knies worth 9, and a team would be dumb to offer sheet him to that. I understand the cap is going up but Knies is not a play driver and his numbers are certainly inflated by his line mates. He’s a guy you’d love to have on your team but he’s not someone you make one of the highest paid on your team.
you sure??? Chyrchun just got 9. Knies only being 22...

Knies-Cooley-Keller
Schmaltz-Iginla-Guenther
 
Last edited:
I think it will be around five or six.
With Marner, Tavares, and Knies, any chance the Leafs would try to move Robertson for a pick to save a little money?

I cannot imagine that Nick Robertson will be a Leaf next year. Continues to be bounced in and out of the lineup, and hopefully they'll leave a spot for Cowan to make the jump.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SPV

Ad

Ad