Glad you like him, I wouldn’t swap Guentzel for him. Feel free to start a poll, would be curious what the HF consensus is of who is the superior player.
Speculation: Matt Murray
- Thread starter SeanMoneyHands
- Start date
Glad you like him, I wouldn’t swap Guentzel for him. Feel free to start a poll, would be curious what the HF consensus is of who is the superior player.
Jules Winnfield
Fleurymanbad
- Mar 19, 2010
- 8,920
- 1,965
I wonder what Murray’s save percentage is without Jack Johnson on the ice. Seriously.
At least against Montreal it was like Johnson was on the ice for most goals against.
I’m too lazy to look it up but if anyone is bored it would probably be an interesting stat.
At least against Montreal it was like Johnson was on the ice for most goals against.
I’m too lazy to look it up but if anyone is bored it would probably be an interesting stat.
Blackhawkswincup
RIP Fugu
Debrincat has been in NHL for 3 years
17-18 = 28 goals + 24 assists for 52 pts in 82 games
18-19 = 41 goals + 35 assists for 76 pts in 82 games
19-20 = 18 goals + 27 assists for 45 pts in 70 games
Yeah 41 goals and 35 assists is Declining
He is 22 yr old coming off year in which he struggled ,, It happens
The push by some to declare his career over and trade him makes no sense
Also Matt Murray blows and is not worth any quality assets via trade at this point and certainly wont be worth $$ he wants on contract
Last edited:
dayner
Registered User
- May 23, 2017
- 135
- 25
Gurglesons
Registered User
Debrincat has been in NHL for 3 years
17-18 = 28 goals + 24 assists for 52 pts in 82 games
18-19 = 41 goals + 35 assists for 76 pts in 82 games
19-20 = 18 goals + 27 assists for 45 pts in 70 games
Yeah 41 goals and 35 assists is Declining
He is 22 yr old coming off year in which he struggled ,, It happens
The push by some to declare his career over and trade him makes no sense
Also Matt Murray blows and is not worth any quality assets via trade at this point and certainly wont be worth $$ he wants on contract
I’m sorry. I like Debrincat a lot and was not speaking ill of him.
I’ve noticed a tons of Hawks fans down on him. That’s all I was speaking towards.
I don’t think Murray would bring back Debrincat and was simply commenting on a Hawks fan’s proposal.
66-30-33
Registered User
That makes me even more confused with that response
Is Debrincat somehow in the dog house for the Hawks now? I wouldn't be happy with swapping Guentzel for Debrincat, but the tone of that post didn't make me think of Debrincat.
I think he was implying the difference is the difference between DeBrincat and Jake and as an outsider that’s probably correct.
Strome > Murray
Guentzel < DeBrincat
Honour Over Glory
#firesully
- Jan 30, 2012
- 81,433
- 45,832
The irony in your rationale is humorous.Debrincat has been in NHL for 3 years
17-18 = 28 goals + 24 assists for 52 pts in 82 games
18-19 = 41 goals + 35 assists for 76 pts in 82 games
19-20 = 18 goals + 27 assists for 45 pts in 70 games
Yeah 41 goals and 35 assists is Declining
He is 22 yr old coming off year in which he struggled ,, It happens
The push by some to declare his career over and trade him makes no sense
Also Matt Murray blows and is not worth any quality assets via trade at this point and certainly wont be worth $$ he wants on contract
"DeBrincat had a down year!"
*Murray has one* - Murray blows!
Hypocrisy, be thy name.
The usual HF rationale with stuff like this - Our team likely needs said player, let me now devalue him to his entire fan base, insulting everyone's intelligence and then act like my team doesn't need that player (when it desperately does since there's literally nothing from within that sniffs like a starter)...
Looks about right, within this thread.
So the options are either trying to hope Lehner comes back (lol, yeah right) or a bunch of goalies 30+ years or older, that might be a stop gap for 2-3yrs before they are done, or a 26yr old goalie that had some down times to start each season, rebounds, then has issues in front of him with his team and his game. Murray has struggled, yeah, but there's proof, very damn good proof, that when he's on his game, he's an elite goalie, I think he's one of those guys that when he's finally traded and now has "his team"...he'll thrive again. There were issues in Pittsburgh for him after the 2nd cup, the Fleury stuff that got into his head, his father passing, his injuries, he's basically just lost his mojo there and a change of scenery is best for both sides, it doesn't mean he sucks though. Beyond ridiculous anyone jumps to that notion and this coming from one of Murray's biggest critics on the Pens board.
Then there's literally the track record for goalies - Age 26-30 is when a lot of goalies "figure it out" and get to their game. Murray peaked super early, then had some struggles, one in which he lost his biggest supporter and family member - His Father.
Look at MAF, he lost his Dad and his whole season went away from him, he needed more time and the VGK traded for Lehner later than they should have, now they have their own goalie controversy.
It's...it's like losing a very close loved one....has some severe impact or something.
Last edited:
Sportsnet Alberta ...one of the top 4 D are being offered..maybe as a package .most likely Larsson
.
Empoleon8771
Registered User
You: Debrincat only had 1 bad off year in which he struggled
Also you: Matt Murray blows and is not worth any quality asset
Par the course for the idiocy that is the main boards, my player who had a bad year just had a down year while your player who had a bad year sucks.
Darren McCord
Registered User
- Dec 15, 2015
- 10,021
- 8,387
Im curious as to why you have DeBrincat over Jake?
DeBrincat makes more money on a shorter contract and has less points per game than Jake over the last 3 seasons. Guentzel had almost as many points as him this year in 30 less games.
It was a mistake I meant to put it the other way to balance value
SingnBluesOnBroadway
Retired
ElPrimeTime
Registered User
I don't feel comfortable trading Larsson until Bouchard has shown he can play top 4 minutes or there is another replacement. IF Bouchard isn't ready, you're running Bear and some combination of Benning/Jones as your top two RD while tying up $9-10 million in goaltending.
ColbyChaos
I am a made up country
Down seasons dont exist in this board. People were saying MacKinnon is just a mediocre first liner after failing to improve after 2014.
If those of you that are speculating Murray will get $6 million are correct, then I’m not sure he has any trade value at all.
Gurglesons
Registered User
To be honest, the sect of fans getting down on Debrincat have been very odd to me.
ColbyChaos
I am a made up country
Per Dobber frozen tools.
2019: Most productive line at even strength Kahun-Strome-DeBrincat
3rd most productive line: Perlini-Strome-DeBrincat
In total 40% of his ev strength production (20pts) was away from Kane and Toews. In fact he scored more with Strome on his line than either of those two at an individual basis(43 pts with Strome on the ice vs 36 with Toews and 35 with Kane)
2019 Guentzel:
EV Points away from Sid: 2
PP points away from Sid: 5
Also you really going to pretend Toews and Kane are comparable to 2 generational talents? Not a great argument there at all tbh. No one is questioning Guentzel had the better 2020 season but Cat's 2019 season is not only more impressive but he was also better in 2018 which was a down year for Guentzel anyway. Also not factoring DeBrincat didnt have a major injury that could be career altering.
Acting like Guentzel is in a different league or much better than debrincat is peak what have you done for me lately mentality
Last edited:
