I wanted Eklund at that spot, but I’m also no scout and was enamored by his skill. Similar to Gaucher who doesn’t do anything flashy. Not comparing the two just comparing the bleh reaction when both were drafted. Where is bsu btw?
If the Ducks chose Eklund, then I wouldn't have minded. McTavish just brought more to the table such as playing center, having an NHL body at age 18, and can play the physical game if need be, which he did in the WJC-18 championship game. We also needed his type of play down the middle for the future b/c we were lacking another top-6 center in our system beyond Zegras. Lundy and Groulx are bottom-6 centers.
I tried sharing that McTavish possessed an abundance of skill beyond shooting the puck with scouting reports, podcast link, twitter links, and video links. He's a dynamic player. Also, that his huge jump in development over one off-season could translate to an even higher ceiling. To be fair, the rest of the scouting media caught on pretty late to McTavish. They relied on McTavish's D-1 season and that's the scouting report that was propagated online. That's what a lot of posters were using to describe McTavish, his D-1 scouting report.
Look at last night's Sharks game showed off McTavish's creativity when Terry was surprised to see the puck on his stick on a one-timer shot-pass from McTavish on the PP. Too bad Terry was surprised by the shot-pass b/c he missed scoring a PP goal.
As for the Gaucher pick, I'm with you. He's a safe, shutdown 3c projectable to go to the NHL. I figured Verbeek didn't want to risk not having a first round pick panning out. Gaucher reminds me a lot of Groulx, tbh. That's the problem, we already have a Groulx and nabbed him in the 2nd round of 2018. In 2021, we drafted another bottom-6 C in Josh Lopina in the 4th round.
I identified RW Snuggerud and C Kulich to be less riskier picks (far less riskier than Lambert) in the draft threads that could provide potential top-6 skills. Plus, it would have fit our current style of drafting late in the first round - which was to continue to add potential top-6 scorers. But that was under Murray.
2019: 29th, LW Tracey
2020: 27th, RW Perreault
But it's really early to tell about late first round picks. We're still waiting on Tracey and Perreault to develop.