Has Cal fallen that hard? He used to look like a lock for future top 4.
I'm a little harder on him than most, but not many people are overly high on him now. I don't think anybody believes his value is a 1st anymore. I think he's gonna be an okay bottom-pairing guy, and there's still some potential to be more. He has good offensive tools, good defensive instincts, but man... the wheels just never developed. At all. He can't make use of his other skills because he just doesn't have the mobility. And, keep in mind, TB has a reputation for improving guys's skating. It just didn't happen with him.
I wouldn't add much to him for Schenn. Basically I'd be willing to trade a long-term bottom-pairing guy with upside for a short-term, stable, bottom-pairing guy.
I think there's probably a belief that Foote is worth more because of his age, and he probably is, in a vacuum. But I think Schenn would make us a better team, honestly.