I still think it's valuable to have a face puncher to relieve the pressure from Ritchie, Clifford and Bunting. I do believe players do alot less running around when a tough guy starts chasing up and down the ice to fight. The NHL code is generally if your gonna run around then your have to answer the bell sometimes. Tkatchuk learned this, he hid behind "I don't fight 4th liners" until kassian had as many goals as a 2nd liner, finally Tkatchuk realized he had to fight.
I think you need a catalyst for physical play, and for the past few years the leafs had had none. In fact often I say leafs skate away as there teammate was being roughed up in front of the opposing net. How many times have we seen players standing in our crease after whistle because they knew nobody was gonna do anything about it? I recall when we acquired Clifford, it was interesting to see how fast players got out of the crease or quit their tough shenanigans when he was standing by.
This team has enough skill, we need someone to put a stop to the skill getting roughed up. With Gabriel, Clifford and Ritchie... I highly highly doubt we will see someone jerking matthews around this year.
I dont want Gabriel because I want a goon, I want Gabriel because he brings enthusiasm and energy. The leafs for a few years now have been boring and without any excitement but high end skill. I just want to expose this team to some physical hockey and hopefully see some culture change. Maybe if the boys are around it enough they will be more comfortable in it.
The minute Gabriel loses his jump, by all means send him packing.