Our Souls at Night (2017) Directed by Ritesh Batra 5A
Well, the big plus here is seeing Jane Fonda and Robert Redford together for the fifth and presumably last time (huge bonus points if you can name four of the five of their movies without googling it). The premise is a pleasant one, what I would call a "theatre" premise, meaning it would have probably worked better as a play. Addie is a lonely old woman and she offers Louis, who also lives alone, a modest proposal. Would he consider sleeping with her at night? Not for sex, but for companionship. Louis, less discontented with his isolation, has to think it over. He ponders it a bit and then agrees. So far, so good. Then the complications start, and eventually romance blooms. With both actors now in their 80's. is the romance plausible? Yup. Redford shows his years but still has charisma to burn, and Fonda looks great, maybe a full quarter century younger than she really is. The problem is the "complications." Virtually everything that happens has "scriptwriter" written all over it, as in "let's see what hoops we can make this pair jump through next." There is the bitter son, the thoughtless buddies, the dying friend, the kid and the dog, and so on. I wish director Ritesh Batra had taken the Blue Valentine approach and just let the actors improvise most of their lines. It worked beautifully for Ryan Gosling and Michelle Williams, and it could have worked just as beautifully here. That being said, Redford is wonderful, one of his best, most subtle performances ever. I wish Our Souls at Night deserved that performance, but it was sort of fun to watch these two stars ply their trade together one more time.
Note: now screening on Netflix
Last edited: