Osprey
Registered User
- Feb 18, 2005
- 28,056
- 11,013
Woman out there in the world mostly alone it's really easy to imagine the story making a much more dramatic turn toward something like that in the hands of other writer/directors. I like that it doesn't do that. Nor does it have any big fights or confrontations or sudden revelations. I get why some folks may want that and/or expect that and lacking that, they see this as bland.
I didn't necessarily want any of that, either. It's not like I was sitting there thinking "I hope that something bad happens to her." You want nothing to happen to her, but, still, at the end of the day, if nothing happens to her, the story can feel bland. It's hard to explain.
I think Nomadland has plenty to say about loss and grief and capitalism and a few other topics but it does it fairly quietly, often just with images. It's a small movie about big things.
I actually don't think that the film says much. I think that it lets audiences fill in the blanks to take the meaning out of it that they put into it. For example, depending on your personal experiences and views, you can interpret it as embracing the past, present or future or as a criticism or celebration of America. I think that that was by design and if everyone praises it for their own reasons, then the filmmakers' mission has been accomplished. That's not a bad thing, IMO. Make the film open to interpretation so that everyone thinks that it's speaking for them. It's clever and I'd probably do the same thing.
Last edited: