Shareefruck
Registered User
I think Oldboy is a Korean movie, but yeah, I'd always recommend subtitles instead of dubs. Dubbing over a movie in another language, to me, is the equivalent of replacing all the great actors in a movie with bad ones, and expecting it to be just as good.Haha yeah his system is easier and more accurate I find. I should definitely thank him for that.
Definitely an interesting take, I've never heard of this before. Now that I think of it, I don't even differentiate movies by company when I watch them aside from the obvious ones like Finding Nemo and Toy Story (I think) being Pixar, maybe I should start taking note of subtle things like the studio and directors if it'll help me pick out more movies.
I liked my neighbour Totoro because the whole movie was based on the children, the dad and granny were secondary characters who were just there to support and enable them. I don't know if Mei was mature but the other young girl was definitely mature like an adult. She'd make lunch for the family, think of bringing an umbrella to her father, understand the hospital situation with rationality all while still being a child at heart (running around dancing and singing, looking for those little gremlin soots or whatever). I can definitely appreciate a movie like that, over the ones like you described earlier, that make children dumber than than they really are.
I'm thinking I should rewatch this movie because I rated it too low
You made me look at it from a different perspective, I didn't really think of the bolded on top of appreciating the maturity of the kids while watching the movie. I just saw it as a movie with no villain or lesson or major plot, just a family living life. A simple movie in short, and there's nothing wrong with that, it's a nice change from regular movies.
I think I'll give it a go in Japanese. I was actually going to ask you guys if I was supposed to watch the original oldboy in Japanese or dubbed but nvm I think you answered it.
For the record, I was actually saying the opposite of the mature thing-- These movies, to me, are evidence that not every movie needs to appeal to the mature, adult sensibilities that most movies are held to, in order to be brilliant. The purity, humanistic care, and simplicity from the POV of children is in many ways more profound. All other kids movies talk down to kids as if their natural sensibilities are inherently inferior to ours and don't need to be treated with equivalent care and respect.
Another movie from Ghibli that is like this is Ponyo, IMO.
Last edited: