The Big Parade (1925) - 9/10 (Really loved it)
In 1917, after America's entrance into The Great War, a son of wealthy parents enlists in the Army, makes a few friends, falls in love with a French girl and experiences the horrors of war. This Hollywood epic from director King Vidor balances drama, romance and comedy, was the second most successful film of the silent era (including being MGM's biggest hit for 14 years, until
Gone With the Wind) and greatly influenced war films to come.
It opens with patriotic enthusiasm as American boys "parade" to war and then moves to France, where our protagonist Jim becomes buddies with a couple of other soldiers and, eventually, begins a playful romance with a local girl, despite the language barrier. It flirts with being a comedy through much of this section because it's lighthearted and funny. Shortly after the midway mark, however, things get serious very quickly and it becomes a full-blown war film that's both exhilarating and grim. At 2.5 hours, the film is quite long, but I think that it's warranted because all of the character development and establishment of a lighthearted tone in the first half makes the second half all the more emotionally powerful. It takes a long while to get to, but the battle scenes in that second half are worth the wait. I was impressed by the few scenes with real biplanes and then blown away during the climactic battle scene as hundreds of men march across a wasteland while literally half a dozen shells
per second explode around it. It's a really impressive portrayal of war, especially for a silent film.
If there's a downside (besides the length, though I was OK with it), it's that much of the film might feel familiar because it likely influenced a lot of later films. For example, there's a foxhole scene that's highly reminiscent of
All Quiet on the Western Front (which wouldn't be written and filmed until several years later), the two buddies (one named "Bull" and the other "Slim") are character types that seem like they're in a lot of later war films and a couple of the romantic scenes are somewhat familiar because they've been copied countless times. Such things make it feel cliched and melodramatic in typical Hollywood style, but I think that it helps to remember that this was made in 1925 and likely had a lot to do with creating those cliches and popularizing that style.
Anyways, though it's long and may not pack quite the same punch after 95 years (whoa), I still loved it and even got a little emotional at the end. In fact, it slowly dawned on me while watching it that I saw it decades ago in a high school history class. It was neat to uncover that buried memory and realize that I watched arguably one of the greatest war films as a teenager and didn't know or appreciate that until now.