The French Connection (1971) - 5/10
Detective Doyle chases a French heroin smuggler in NYC. It didn't really leave an impression when I last saw it over 20 years ago, so I decided to re-watch it in hopes that I would see this time why it won Best Picture. Honestly, I still don't understand. It does have a terrific car chase with an elevated train and an entertaining cat-and-mouse game in a subway station, but the rest is less exciting and a bit nonsensical. For one, I still don't understand how they returned the car to its owner in like new condition after they literally sawed and ripped it into hundreds of pieces. Also, it has an ambiguous ending, which is not really satisfying for a crime thriller, but what's worse is that the film clears it up in the postscript. What's the point of leaving the audience guessing if you give them the answer seconds later? Overall, it felt like a good enough crime thriller, but I can't really see what makes it exceptional, besides the iconic car chase. Maybe it was a weak Oscar year or I've just seen so many crime thrillers that were made since that I can't imagine how fresh and exciting it felt in 1971. Then again, I don't have any problem understanding why
The Godfather,
Jaws,
Star Wars and
Alien are exceptional, despite over 40 years of copycats in those sub-genres. Who knows.
French Connection II (1975) - 5/10
Detective Doyle chases a French heroin smuggler in Marseilles. I hadn't seen this before, probably because I assumed that it was bad. It actually isn't, though it's not that good, either. "Unnecessary" is the best way to describe it. I'm curious as to whether they made a sequel to a Best Picture winner because they couldn't resist capitalizing on it or they actually thought that they could repeat the feat. I'm at least pretty sure that Gene Hackman thought that he might win Best Actor again because, for one, a third of the film is an acting clinic for him as his character is under the influence of drugs and then goes through really bad withdrawals that include a lot of yelling and curling up into a fetal position. It felt a little over the top, but at least he didn't mail it in like actors can do when they do a sequel for the paycheck. I liked that Popeye Doyle is in France this time and can't speak a lick of the language, and that he walks into a crowded restaurant with a can of gasoline, spills it all around the customers and lights it with a match before anyone can get out.
The film has more action than the original, but lacks a similarly epic chase scene. It does try to recreate it by having Doyle chase a trolley on foot, but, needless to say, it's not nearly as effective. Anyways, it felt like an average crime thriller. Then again, so did the original that won Best Picture, so what do I know.