A Real Pain (2024) Directed by Jessie Eisenberg
5B
As their deceased Grandma wanted, two cousins, David (Jesse Eisenberg) and Benji (Kieran Culkan) spend part of their inheritance on a guided tour of Poland in which they visit various WW II historical sites, including Nazi death camps. David is thoughtful and conventional, but Benji is an unpredictable wild card who nonetheless has the ability to charm his way out of some of the socially awkward situations that he gets himself (and David) into in the first place. There is not a lot of plot here, just a slowly deepening examination of a couple of young Jewish men trying to find a way to respond to a cultural heritage that they have yet to fully come to grips with. Misleadingly billed as a comedy,
A Real Pain provides little laughter as it really is about dealing with pain, both historical and personal. Culkan's bravura performance has sincerity going for it, but his is not a character with whom I wanted to spend much time. I found Eisenberg just plain annoying--the same facial expressions and nervous mannerisms that he brings to every role he is ever in are once again in evidence. It seems he can only portray one character, and for me, anyway, that character is wearing very thin.
A Real Pain is a good enough movie for what it does, sort of like
Sideways, except, as one commentator pointed out, with a focus not on wineries but on concentration camps. Ultimately kind of a downer.