nameless1
Registered User
- Apr 29, 2009
- 18,202
- 1,020
Vagabond (1985) - 7/10
Sandrine Bonnaire plays an intriguingly crude if not completely believable vagabond in what's less of a movie and more of a tale of events if that makes sense. I think some people love this sort of narrative structure and find it refreshing, I find it mixed with some good and some poor scenes while maybe not enjoying it as much because of my distaste for watching distasteful characters for long periods.
Varda does not do a lot of fictional narrative work, but I am always more fascinated by those than her documentaries. Cleo from 5 to 7 will always be No. 1, but I really like this one too.
When I first watched it, I just discovered that the library had a trove of Criterion Collection DVDs, so I went on a tear, and this was one of the first films I borrowed. The opening two scenes always stick out to me, where it shows the crime scene of the protagonist's death at the beach, and then immediately goes the real start of the narrative, when she emerges from the sea. That juxtaposition immediately brings to my mind The Little Mermaid, and as a result, I am hooked, and become intrigued by how the film will proceed. In the end, it is indeed a re-imagination of the fairy tale, but unlike the original tale, where eponymous character died by choice, she is simply grinded down by the everyday problems of the world, like poverty, addiction, and homelessness, until there is nothing left of her. Thus, Varda's tale hits a lot harder, because it is a more accurate reflection of our times.
The most impressive aspect of the film is Varda's inspired choice to mix the fictional narrative and a documentary interview style, because since different people have a different opinion of the eponymous character, she becomes a fully fleshed out three-dimensional character, and the audience can fully connect with her, and subsequently, the film.
In the years since the film's release, numerous filmmakers have tried this narrative style, but almost all of them failed to replicate Varda's magic. Ann Hui, another director I deeply admire, tried in 2014's Golden Era, where the main character tells the audience of her death in the first scene, but I basically lose interest immediately. That just makes me realize how hard it is to make this particular narrative where the main character is already dead from the start to work, and as I watched more films in subsequent years, it just makes me appreciate this film even more. Even with Varda's renowned reputation, I truly think that she may even be considered underrated, because even though her films may not always work, she can always make any story interesting, no matter how dull the subject matter can be. There is just something with her control of the narrative style that makes her characters interesting, even if they are rather stoic and do not immediately demonstrate colourful personalities.
Last edited: