KallioWeHardlyKnewYe
Hey! We won!
- May 30, 2003
- 15,772
- 3,808
White Noise. This book was given to me when I was in college and has now moved with me through god 7-8 different homes and multiple book shelves over 20+ years. Sad to say it took the release of an adaptation of it to finally get me to read it, but such is life. So within the last week I both read the book and watched the movie. LIked the book. Kinda indifferent to the movie. The oddest thing about this binge is that I feel like I actually like the movie MORE having read the book first than I would have if I just saw the movie. I might have even hated the movie had I not read the book. Normally it feels like it's the other way around.
The book prepped me for people who I otherwise might have found intolerable.
Novelist Don DeLillo really deserves a co-writing credit on the screenplay, which is incredibly faithful to his dialogue. The dialogue plays great in the book, but less so on screen. I admire the fealty although I'm not sure it totally works. Some of it does. There are some quite funny sequences and exchanges, but as a whole I was left sorta "meh" about the whole affair.
The big sin is that despite their best efforts I'm not sure Adam Driver and especially Greta Gerwig are the right fits for their roles. There's a big confrontation about two-thirds in that is true to the book, but while it's dryly funny in the novel, it's played for emotion here and it completely falls flat because the leads and their relationship just isn't established in a way where we really care about these people it suddenly asks us to care for. The final third (again despite being fairly true to the book) didn't work for me because of that shift.
Looks pretty good. Great Spielberg Face moment (you'll know it when you see it). A few genuinely funny scenes (the river evacuation, a discussion with a nun to name two).
But again, I'm more indifferent to it than down on it. Ironically that is perhaps a fitting reaction given its tone.
The book prepped me for people who I otherwise might have found intolerable.
Novelist Don DeLillo really deserves a co-writing credit on the screenplay, which is incredibly faithful to his dialogue. The dialogue plays great in the book, but less so on screen. I admire the fealty although I'm not sure it totally works. Some of it does. There are some quite funny sequences and exchanges, but as a whole I was left sorta "meh" about the whole affair.
The big sin is that despite their best efforts I'm not sure Adam Driver and especially Greta Gerwig are the right fits for their roles. There's a big confrontation about two-thirds in that is true to the book, but while it's dryly funny in the novel, it's played for emotion here and it completely falls flat because the leads and their relationship just isn't established in a way where we really care about these people it suddenly asks us to care for. The final third (again despite being fairly true to the book) didn't work for me because of that shift.
Looks pretty good. Great Spielberg Face moment (you'll know it when you see it). A few genuinely funny scenes (the river evacuation, a discussion with a nun to name two).
But again, I'm more indifferent to it than down on it. Ironically that is perhaps a fitting reaction given its tone.