The Black Phone (2022) - 6/10
Locked in a soundproof basement, an abducted boy begins receiving calls on a supposedly disconnected phone. This was fairly creepy and suspenseful. It was obvious from early on what was happening, so there wasn't any surprise or twist in store, but it was still chilling. There are a few jump scares and disturbing imagery, but it's more of a psychological thriller than a horror. I really liked how much it looked and felt like 1978. Overall, it has a Stephen King vibe along the lines of It. The two young actors, especially the one playing the sister, were good. A lot of the film is about the two siblings' relationship, which provides the emotional foundation for the film. Ethan Hawke is sufficiently creepy as the always-masked kidnapper who could drop the "nice" act at any moment and become terrifying, though a little more insight into his character and motivations would've been nice. A lot of the film felt a little bit undercooked like that. It's not quite as scary, suspenseful or emotional as it could've been and the ending left me with several unanswered questions. It didn't quite live up to the hype, but I still enjoyed watching it.
Sinister (2012) - 5/10
A true crime novelist (Ethan Hawke) moves his family into a house where another family was recently brutally murdered because it seemed like a good idea at the time. After watching The Black Phone, I read that it was a return to his roots for Scott Derrickson, the writer/director, so I decided to check out this earlier film of his along the same lines. It's definitely horror and full of creepy imagery and jump scares, though I didn't find it quite as creepy as it should've been and the jump scares were predictable. I also half-jokingly predicted one of the final twists only 15 minutes in. The whole thing was probably 20 minutes too long, as well. I did like the family drama, especially the believable arguing between the husband and wife. It turns out that you should probably tell your spouse when you move the family into the site of a mass murder. Good to know. I also liked the acting and the bold ending. The movie felt predictable and clichéd for the first 90% of it, but was refreshingly different for the final 10%, like "this never happens in horror movies" different. That redeemed it a little, but a good twist or two at the end doesn't make up for an hour and a half of clichés. It wasn't bad as horror movies go, but it's probably not something that I'll care to watch again.
The Exorcism of Emily Rose (2005) - 7/10
A lawyer (Laura Linney) defends a parish priest (Tom Wilkinson) on trial for the death of a girl after a failed exorcism. While looking up Scott Derrickson's filmography after watching The Black Phone, this stood out to me along with Sinister, so I watched it, as well. It's a unique blend of courtroom drama and horror film that's based on a true story. It opens with Emily Rose already being dead and her story is told from the witness stand via flashbacks. They provide the film's horror elements as we see what hell she supposedly went through. They're creepy and unnerving, but those expecting a horror film might be a little disappointed. It's as much, if not more, of a legal movie, but a different one than most because of the subject matter. The intersection of faith and justice was interesting, especially the fact that a priest is on trial for just trying to help and being prosecuted by a fellow Christian and defended by an agnostic. It felt like a pretty intelligent and balanced script to me. While the flashbacks paint a picture of possession, the fact that they're the testimony of potentially unreliable witnesses allows the film to get away with not establishing or denying the existence of the supernatural. It raises the question of whether you need to believe in the supernatural explanation in order to excuse someone who does of wrongdoing. The leads are good, but Jennifer Carpenter as the tormented Emily gives one of the more committed performances that I've seen. Kudos to her for a very physically unflattering role. I wouldn't say that it's very strong as a courtroom drama or as a horror film, but, as a combination of the two, it's refreshingly unique. I like both genres, so it was right up my alley.