Kaili Blues / 路边野餐 (Bi Gan, 2015)
When Chen’s neglected nephew is sold by his half-brother into servitude, Chen travels from Kaili City to a mysterious village to search for him. Well, at least that’s loosely what the plot is about. While this plot description sounds like a Chinese knockoff of
Taken, Kaili Blues is the furthest thing from an action or thriller movie. Kaili Blues is a slow cinema film that is a Buddhist meditation on memory and the blurring of the past, present, and future. With Bi’s focus on the forgotten and left behind of Chinese rush for development and his use of Buddhist poetry and themes and mysticism, Kaili Blues feels like a blending of the films of Jia Zhangke and Apichatpong Weerasethakul. Bi’s work is extremely beautiful and creative, there are some really impressive shots and tricks he uses.
Most notably, there is a 40-minute-long single take that follows the protagonist through the dreamy world he ends up in for his journey to find his nephew. Long takes of that length are almost always impressive to me (when done well) due to the planning and coordination involved to do it right, and for the viewer's perspective the lack of cutting puts you in the character’s sense of space and time. This is effective for this film since the film blurs these temporal and spatial boundaries as the film explores the blending of past, present, and future. It’s a very effective move for this film and it’s mostly well executed.
However, a frequent criticism of films which feature extended long takes are that they are gimmicky. Bi Gan has directed two films so far, this one and
Long Day’s Journey Into Night, and both of these films feature extended 40 minute plus long takes in the 2nd halves of the films. I had previously seen
Long Day’s Journey Into Night and I enjoyed it and was impressed by his use of the long take to explore temporal and spatial boundaries. However, now that I’ve seen both his feature films, his use of the long take begins to shift in my perspective from impressive and creative to gimmicky territory as it makes him seem like a bit of a one trick pony. If I had only seen one or the other, the magic of it would have sustained, but watching both and seeing the same trick used it seems gimmicky. Bi is undoubtedly a talent to watch, but I would like to see if he has some different tricks up his sleeve.
@kihei I know you're a big fan of both Jia Zhangke and Apichatpong Weerasethakul, I'm curious if you've seen either of Bi Gan's works and what your thoughts are of him. He seems like someone up your alley (If not,
Long Day's Journey Into Night is his more polished work)