NyQuil
Big F$&*in Q
The Punisher (1989) - 4/10
I couldn't remember if I'd seen this, but some parts were familiar, so I must've. It's sure not a memorable movie. Something that surprised me is that Dolph Lundgren looked rather "small" in it compared to how he looked the previous year in Red Scorpion. See what I mean...
Maybe that's just what happens when a Swede loses his blond hair? I'm not very familiar with the comic book, but it didn't feel like it could've been very faithful. For one, Dolph didn't seem very vengeful, maybe because his family had been dead for years and the Yakuza weren't the ones responsible for it, either. It felt more like a generic 80s action movie. I certainly have a soft spot for those, which is why I'm giving as high of a score as I am, but this is one of the forgettable ones and I'll probably forget again that I watched it.
Same guy one year later:
The Punisher (2004) - 5/10
This was actually better than I expected (though I expected pretty bad). I appreciated that it's a modern "superhero" movie that doesn't involve any super powers or CGI. I'm partial to Batman and Darkman for that reason and it reminded me of both. It was dark and not too corny, Thomas Jane made for a decent lead and watching bad things happen to John Travolta was satisfying. I liked parts of it, but other parts not so much. It had some good visuals, action scenes and explosions, but also dragged at times and was too long (good thing that I elected not to watch the extended cut). In spite of its problems and not quite "liking" it, I'd still take it over most of the superhero CGI-fests.
The best version of the story is the Marvel miniseries starring Jon Bernthal.