Well it could be that he didn't have anything to do with the search, but with Malkin/Collins f***ing it up pretty badly, they're (considering) inviting Lou back in.
If you piece it all together since Malkin took over I think it went something like this...
- 2018 - Malkin buys Islanders.
- His standard/capability is much higher than Wang's, so he wants to get rid of Snow, but...Is a "rookie" so doesn't know who to hire.
- With Shanahan/Dubas in Toronto, Lou on his way out.
- Bettman/NHL put Lou/Malkin together.and off they go.
- Malkin settles into ownership and starts to get familiar with the NHL landscape, but has a lot on his plate, so in 2023 hires/sells partial ownership to John Collins and let's him run the business side of the Isles.
- Over the past year(s), Collins doesn't agree with Lou's direction/they get into a power struggle, and (part-owner) Collins wins out and Lou's contract is not renewed.
- Collins, with Malkin's support, starts a search for a President/GM.
- For whatever reason they keep Lou around. And if he's around, he's sharing his opinion.
- And perhaps because Lou is incredibly close with Ken Holland...They solely with laser-focus on Holland, but he's hesitant and keeps the Isles at arm's length.
- Finally 1-2 weeks go by and Malkin/Collins have to consider other names (you'll notice that as of 24 hours ago they still hadn't reached out to Bergevin, Jarmo, Darche, etc).
- Seems like the reason Bergevin's name was out there was because he/his agent were sharing their interest, but Isles don't seem to have interest in him.
- Jarmo perhaps even less.
- That's why now with Holland seemingly uninterested, you're hearing names like Darche, and "Lou might stay on to mentor another young/less experienced candidate.
Where it goes from here is just scary. Lou needs to be cut out and sent to Siberia immediately. If Malkin/Collins cannot both identify, and hire, and compent President/GM then they are not capable owners.