I think of the current d-men on the roster, he would probably be the 4th best at playing actual defense.
Guhle and Savard are both better, Matheson and Struble are debatable, but he is clearly better at actual defensive hockey than Xhekaj or Barron currently.
I think Matheson actually gets shit on too much for his defensive ability - he gets lost in coverage when the other team has sustained pressure, but he breaks up so many plays with his skating and decent stick work.
I was impressed with Struble this preseason but Xhekaj and Barron are both turnstiles right now. It's clear the scouting report is out on Xhekaj too as teams take him wide every game and he can't keep up.
Matheson's issue for me is that his value would have never been higher than it was after last season. For his price, he's a completely fine #3 type guy... who we have to use as #1 right now by default. 26 minutes a night is too much for him. He reminds me a lot of Brisebois in that sense - though he's a bit better defensively. I don't dislike Matheson as a person or even a player overall, I dislike that we could have got a ransom for him and let that pass.
I agree with the rest.. and I think Kova's offensive ability is a bit underrated. I think, with Top-4 ice-time, he could have been a 20-ish point player on our team, which is fair production for that spot and his zone starts.
Again, I've never said we shouldn't trade him. I said the trade we made was poor, especially for when it happened. If this happened a couple weeks before the season when they had their defense set - sure. But it's sad that our defense, IMO, is worse defensively than even last year and we're supposed to be moving forward.
Well, I'm not going to die because of my opinion.
This types of posts are wild to me. Without opinions, this place would have zero posts. Like what?
Seriously.............................Kovacevic is the hill you want to take??
He was decent, and I liked he would drop the gloves, which was great to take pressure off of The Sheriff, but that's it................he was always going to be the guy going, and Harris too.
Both had great traits.......but they were expendable.
If we kept Engstrom up, I'd have less of an issue (even though I'd still think the trade was bad). But f***ing Justin Barron?