Considering he's only played a handful of NHL games, I don't think anyone is confident that Newhook will be able to carry a line as a 2C. I'd still rather give him a shot to show what he can do this season before we make a bunch of moves to try to ensure that he never gets the chance. Best case, we keep all of our assets and have a 2C. Worst case, we can try to sign Hertl as a UFA.
But, I also struggle with the idea that Hertl is a long term solution. He currently has a $5.625 cap hit, and could easily be in the $7m range in UFA. We're already near the cap with Kadri at $4.5m, and have some expensive decisions to make in the near future, so I'm not sure where the extra cap space is coming from.